Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 20, 2024

HOW TO ENSURE “AFFORDABLE” SCHOOL FEES?

Last week parliament tasked the education ministry with outlining punitive measures for schools that charge prohibitive fees.

This is

a perennial lament that pops up around the first term, when parents coming out of the merry making of the festive season, “suddenly” realise school fees are “too expensive”.

The representatives of the people jump on the sentiment and criticise the government in general and the education ministry, in particular for the high fees schools are charging.

This time they have gone a step further and demanded that the education ministry punish schools, which charge exorbitant fees.

You never know whether to laugh or cry in these situations.

There are a number of issues here, not least of all is how do you  determine what are exorbitant fees.

A man who was used to driving free of charge on Entebbe road may think the sh5000 a trip on Entebbe expressway is exorbitant; A man who is used to drinking a beer at his local Kafunda at sh3000 may scream bloody murder when he goes to one of our higher establishments and they charge him sh10,000 for beer; A man used to paying sh1,000 in a taxi may have some uncharitable words to say when the Uber driver charges him sh15,000 for the same trip into town.

Even more fundamentally, the MPs were not calling for sanctions on government schools but on private schools, which government ideally should have no business setting caps on what they charge as fees.

"Putting a cap on fees will disincentivise investment in the sector and lead to the very thing MPs are complaining about – exorbitant fees...

About 10 million children are enrolled in primary and secondary schools around the country. In Kampala 84 percent of them are enrolled in private institutions. In the countryside this falls away considerably depending on the earning power of the population.

If parliament wants to sustainably lower school fees they need to take a long hard look at that ratio. That number screams for more investment by government in the sector.  

With the power to appropriate budgets, MPs should be talking about increasing the funding to the sector to build, man and equip more schools as a way to bring fees down.

It’s a simple demand and supply equation. The more government schools there are of credible quality the less the gap for the private schools to fill in.

In Sweden where government provides free education for every child of school going age,  private schools account for less than a fifth of all enrolment. 

Tuesday, March 28, 2023

UPE AND THE FLIGHT FROM POVERTY

Getting out of poverty follows a simple formula.

But first what is poverty? Poverty generally, is the inability to meet your basic needs. The opposite of which is being rich, where you can not only met your basic needs, but have surplus income that comes from your assets.

"The formula of getting out of poverty is to trade value for income and with that income create more value and therefore more income. A virtuous cycle. A simple formula but not easy to execute...

The trick is to have something – a good or service, of value to trade. It is possible to have value and fail to trade it, either because there is no market for it or that the market is not aware of your value, but that’s a discussion for another day.

At the heart of the challenge for most anti-poverty programs is how do you create value and then get it to market, and do this sustainably over time.

The reason you are poorer than the richest man in your town is because he knows something you don’t. What he knows that you don’t, makes him behave in a way that ensures he earns more than you.

So invariably creating value often comes with mindset change.

Last week the education ministry commemorated the 25 years of Universal Primary Education (UPE) program. What started off as a response to a campaign promise by presidential candidate Paul Ssemogerere in  1996, was a good idea that was long overdue. Since then primary enrollment has jumped to  about eight million today from two million in 1996 and seen literacy levels  almost double to 75 percent from 43 percent in 1986.

As suggested above education, which by definition entails a mindset change and therefore creation of value, is a useful first step to lift people out of poverty.

There are questions about the content of our education system, but if one is literate can overcome these shortcomings with continuous learning.

It should come as no surprise that Kenya and Tanzania, which in the case of the former has had bigger enrollments at primary school or in the case of the latter started UPE in 1977 are bigger economies than Uganda. Their literacy levels reflect the earlier adoption of UPE with Kenya at 82 percent and Tanzania 81 percent.

"The thing with such social engineering initiatives is that it takes time to see tangible results, which may discourage people with shorter electoral time spans. But the benefits are there, its just that they may just creep up on you.

What value can you put on being able to communicate in one language all around the country? How much easier is trade? How much easier is it to mobilise populations? How much market do you create when more of us are educated or at least literate?

It’s happening already. While ideally we should be communicating in an indigenous language other than English, you can now go anywhere in the country and manage just fine with English, as most people now have studied English to some basic level. Hopefully with the introduction of Kiswahili at primary school, in another 25 years we should more improved communication around the country.

That being said there is a lot to be done. The education ministry reports that there is no government aided school in 1,617 of the more than 10,000 parishes in the country.

The ministry estimates that it will need sh1.89trillion or about sh1.2b per school to bridge this gap. Apart from questions of value for money there really should not be any hesitation in releasing these funds.

The best investment a nation can make is to invest in its people, and providing education as well as health services should be key.

A country like Singapore with a tenth of our population and for all intents and purposes, a rock in the sea has a GDP of about $400b.  Beyond basic literacy Singapore’s education system is ranked in the top 20 in the world. It helps of course that there has been an education system in that country since 1823.

Coming full circle to poverty eradication, there are two ways that I know of for an individual to create value, either through education or experience.

UPE has its issues. The idea is sound but the execution may be wanting.

"A previous generation, which did the proverbial 10 mile trek to and from school, have countless stories about how education made a difference. In single families there are siblings who had climbed out of poverty and others who were wallowing in poverty, the difference being one sibling went to school and the other did not.

Interestingly they started their schooling writing in the dust using sharpened pieces of wood (we call them stylus these days), often under trees and many times there was no school when it rained.

They came out fine and many of them lead or have led this country.


 

 

 

 

Monday, January 9, 2023

EDUCATION MINISTRY HEADING DOWN A SLIPPERY SLOPE

 The education ministry’s plan to regulate school fees in private schools is baffling because it goes against the spirit of the sector’s liberalization and is curious given our history with price controls.

A statutory instrument is in the offing to put caps on school fees from pre-primary to tertiary levels for all schools.

One can imagine that the move is in response to parents’ complaints about rising fees, especially last year when inflation jumped to its highest level in eight years.

It is ironic that the ministry would even consider regulating private school fees at all.

"When the NRM came to power in 1986 the need for more widespread provision of education services were clear. Less than half the school going children were in school, a number that had to be increased dramatically as a long-term investment in the future of the country...

The introduction of UPE in 1997 more than doubled enrollment.

However, prior to this government opened the doors to private institutions, which have been critical in providing education. At last count private schools accounted for 40 percent of the enrolled students in the system.

This is not the first time calls for fees to be controlled by government have been voiced, but the government has swatted back such calls.

The logic as I understood it, was quite simple. The government does not have the resources to provide universal education and therefore coopted the private sector to help in this endeavor.

The private sector recognized the opportunity and have been quick to take advantage. The explosion in private schools is an indication that it is a lucrative enough market in which to play.

There was reasonable certainty that if an investor committed funds, he could cover his costs and have some profit left over from the school fees they charge. Going by the competition, school owners could only charge so much, otherwise they would collapse due to more inexpensive competition.

Over the yeas investors in the sector have found an equilibrium, with fees shifting depending on economic circumstances.

The government on the other hand continued to struggle with provision of quality education in its schools and those parents who could opted for private education.

"One of the major byproducts of this increased private sector participation is that our education is biased more than ever towards passing exams and away from building well rounded, upright citizens of the country....

It makes sense. The most objective way to measure success and therefore to market ones school is by showing that they can churn out academic successes. So many schools do not bother with extracurricular activities – many don’t have a blade of grass to call their own. Though some argue that this is down to a failure of the education ministry’s inspection and enforcement of regulation concerning the setting up of schools.

However, if government enforced all the standards, it is arguable whether there would be as many private schools as they are now, as meeting all these requirements may make the investment unviable given the fees the market currently allow.

This last point is interesting because it suggests that schools are actually charging less than they should. A business man will do just enough to earn a margin on the costs of the business. So, if he can cheat on standards he can get better margins.

Relatedly the private sector is in education because there is a gap in the sector, both in terms of number and the quality of schools. The quality of education anywhere is determined by the public schools, the better they are the less likely there are to be private schools and the few that are there will be charging a premium...

Given government’s inability to keep pace with the growth in the school going population, controlling prices will cause the very thing that they fear – higher school fees.

This is how it will come about. You control fees and some businessmen will decide the sector is no longer viable and drop out. Best case scenario, they will sell to other businessmen who want to try their luck, worst case scenario they will repurpose the building for other uses and that would be a school lost.

In the worst-case scenario that will mean more students in fewer available schools. The disparity between supply and demand would widen, which in normal times would force an increase in school fees. But because government will have put a cap on fees, schools will find all sort of ingenious ways to charge more.

Invariably there will be some proprietors who would rather not play cat and mouse with government and fall by the wayside, further aggravating the demand-supply balance. All the while you can bet that government schools will not be getting better able to sponge up these kids who have no schools to go to.

"In the end the very thing the ministry is hoping against – runaway school fees prices, will come to pass and for much poorer quality service...

 


Monday, October 11, 2021

MTN’S JOURNEY FROM START UP TO THE STOCK EXCHANGE

I remember it like it was yesterday. The first day that telecom company MTN opened for business. I stood in line to get my MTN number, one of hundreds with sh70,000 clenched firmly in one hand and phone in the other. The sim card cost sh30,000 the rest was loaded on the phone as airtime.

Up to that point the sole mobile phone provider Celtel, used to charge for airtime in US dollars and had a punitive service fee  – it cost $10, which lasted a weekend when time was up you could neither receive nor call out.

Their airtime too was very expensive because in November 1998 – my first full month on MTN, the accountants had to call me in because my MTN airtime claim had fallen to sh200,000 from $400 paid to Celtel the previous month, for the same volume of work. The dollar then was about sh1,300.

"But our joy of shedding off the shackles of Celtel were short lived as the MTN system soon, within the hour crashed under the weight of the new numbers. I later learnt that MTN had installed a 14,000-line switch at Mbuya, the planners thought that would be good for a few months were soon back to the drawing board...

I would have paid to be a fly on the wall at the swanky new Celtel headquarters, which they bragged had cost sh4b, when they saw their subscriber numbers fall off a cliff that day.

At the time Uganda was at the tail end of its privatization effort and was moving into the more intricate liberalization phase. I covered the search for a Second Network Operator (SNO) as a journalist and one of MTN’s target as the SNO was to sign up 89,000 new subscribers within five years.  That doesn’t seem like much today but at the time Uganda Posts & Telecommunications Corporation (UPTC) the state owned telecom company had 50,000 subscribers. It was later split in to, which was split into UTL, Posta and Postbank.

By the end of the next year MTN had surpassed its 89,000-line target and I heard there were mutterings in the corridors, that the condition was for copper lines – used by the old analogue phones and not mobile phone lines. Probably a shakedown operation.

MTN has never looked back and to see them in action now one would think they were the pioneers of mobile telephony in this country.

But it’s not only the telecom industry that was shook up.

A few years later MTN went to the banks to borrow the billions it needed to keep up with the huge suppressed demand. I don’t remember the details but the bond the issued for the money was supposed to last five years but after the second year they wanted to pay off the debt. One bank refused to take back their money. Their argument was that they had planned on those cashflows coming in over the next few years and to take the money back now would throw their budget off.

So today when MTN – this country’s only billion-dollar company, announces the details of their share offer, it will belie an adventure the South African company embarked on in 1998 that, along the way, has paid off handsomely for its investors, the economy and its users.

Because people forget that Uganda was MTN’s first market outside South Africa and the one, which pointed to the huge demand for the unique kind of service they could provide, having cut their teeth in the townships of South Africa.

"It’s the Ugandan experience, which emboldened them to go into Nigeria, which long overtook South Africa as its biggest market....

MTN plans to sell about one trillion shillings’ worth of shares over the next six weeks to the public. The price of a share will be announced today but following what is becoming our rule of thumb, one can expect it will be cheaper than a bottle of soda.

While the Umeme share offer of almost 10 years ago raised more than sh100b more than the Stanbic offer, the bank’s offer has been the most exciting to date, but MTN’s offer is set to move the excitement needle beyond red. Not only is it almost ten times bigger than the Umeme offer but MTN’s top of mind recognition among the public is universal and that will count for a lot.

Interestingly across the border the Safaricom initial Public Offer (IPO) in 2008 was also the most exciting share offer on the older Nairobi Stock Exchange (NSE) at the time. At the time Safaricom dominated the mobile phone market, accounting for almost four in every five subscribers and was just getting into data services and M-Pesa – their world renown mobile money service. They have maintained their dominance in the market, some would say have cemented it, and their share price has risen eightfold since the IPO.

MTN now is around where Safaricom was then.

 


 

 

 

 

Tuesday, March 9, 2021

THE FATE OF SCHOOLS AND WHAT'S TO BE DONE

Last week it was reported that many schools are folding under the weight of Covid-19 and are on the chopping block, with promoters seeking to shed themselves of them.

You have to feel for the owners who for many, through no fault of their own, are in this distressed situation.

On a more global level the collapse of these schools will have far reaching consequences on the sector, which is driven mainly by the private schools.

There was a time when public schools and those set up by religious groups dominated the sector. But underinvestment in the 1970s and 1980s, population growth and this government’s commitment to Universal Primary Education (UPE) meant the demand for education, of whatever sort burst through the roof.

The private sector jumped at the opportunity. As a result, there has been a boom in the education sector in the last few years. One businessman with interests in real estate and finance when he made an entrance into the school business, said it was the easiest money to make.

"Covid-19 and the measures government took to contain it brought the gravy train to a screeching halt. And as it is with any crisis, you will know who was swimming naked when the tide goes out...

Not to kick a man when he is down, but for all of us the old saying that, make hay while the sun shines has never been truer.

A cursory analysis of the most distressed schools shows three rough patterns.

The worst hit are the new schools who had just begun, had not broken even and were in “the valley of death”  -- that stage in any business’ development before the business model has been proven.

The second group are those who while they have been around for a bit still have massive fixed costs, especially rent, which they still owed while the schools were shut down and not earning any income.

The third group and probably the most tragic, to my mind, are those whose schools were established, had even invested in their own premises, had not quite created a brand but worse still they had no buffer fund to tide them over the hard times.

This last case the proprietors were content to eat all surpluses, the schools were indebted up to the eyeballs and when the first bump in the road came they collapsed like a pack of cards.

Not to oversimplify the issue, but many distressed schools find themselves facing a variation of one of these themes.

Moral hazard – reckless behavior by borrowers knowing they will be saved from themselves, aside, the government needs to look into how they bailout the education sector.

Already of course, the market, which waits for no man, has jumped into the fray, with distressed owners putting their enterprises up for sale.

The challenge with the market is that while it is the most effective creator of wealth the world has known, it is the worst distributor of that same wealth. It tends to give more to those who have and take away even the little that the poor have. The challenge of leaving the education sector’s current woes to be resolved by the market is that one, this may very well lead to concentration of the sector in the hands of a few people, who have the funds to buy all these distressed assets. We shouldn’t begrudge people their hard work, but one effect of such a scenario is that they will be able to charge as much as they want for lack of competition.

Which might not be the worst thing though.

"The worst thing is if the school owners find no buyers, which may affect thousands of learners, who may not be easily absorbed in the existing schools. It was reported last year that in Kenya some school owners had turned the premises into poultry farms and the returns were such that they were not contemplating a return to the education sector.

Education is not a service a country can do without. It is an essential service that can very well determine the fate of a nation. As it is, experts are already warning that the makings of greater economic inequality are being sown between those students who have continued learning online and those who cannot for whatever reason, but mostly because their parents are already poor.

The nature of the interventions will of course determine whether the education sector comes out the other side with the minimum of pain or distorts it even further. Any bailout must be to the most deserving school, with the main parameter being schools which have the most impact on the most vulnerable communities.

The nature of bailout can range from taking over the schools altogether, restructuring their debt or even providing a grant.

The point is these are not shops or other private enterprises we can abandon to the vagaries of the market. Something systematic and effective needs to be done. Sooner than later.

Monday, November 4, 2019

MAKERERE UNIVERSITY RUNNING OUT OF ROAD TO KICK THE CAN


The events at Makerere University this last week were saddening but not surprising.

Students took to the streets to protest a planned 15% increment in their fees and came face to face with security agents who were deployed to quell the fracas.

It was never going to end properly if they army were unleashed – untrained in putting down civilian unrest, on the students. It was even more ominous when the press were kept off the campus.

It took the intervention President Yoweri Museveni for some kind of settlement to be arrived at. The university authorities did a climb down, announcing the 15% increment would only be applied to tuition and not to the facilitation fees.

Strikes -- protesting low pay by the teaching and non-teaching staff and increments in students fees, have become a perennial affair. After a few days of disagreement, a band aid solution is arrived at and normalcy returns to the University, but just for a while.

"The government and leadership at Makerere have been content to kick the can down the road year after year, ensuring that the real challenges not the symptoms fester and boil over every year.

The challenge of Makerere and other public universities is one of leadership. Inadequate resources, the falling quality of the output and now the perennial strikes are all but symptoms of poor leadership.

How is it that the square mile with highest concentration of brain power in the country, maybe even in the region, has failed to solve the simple equation of admitting a youthful population, accommodating them in relative comfort, imparting knowledge and graduating useful members of society without drama?

In fact the market is becoming increasingly dubious of its graduates, which suggests the former Harvard of Africa is not keeping up with the times. You shall be judged by your fruit, they say.

"It starts with the way the university’s chief executive officer is selected, an archaic process that rewards popularity rather than competence....

You can paper over the leadership inadequacies when you have a student body of less 500, like at Independence – making it a privilege not a right, you have a monopoly on university education and you are operating in an analogue world, where change takes place at a glacial pace.

But when you have a student body of 35,000-plus whose numbers have outstrip the infrastructure, competing with several other institutions for government support and with added baggage of a reputation the selection of the CEO has to go beyond academic cronyism.

Assuming a student body of 35,000 paying on average a million shillings a semester, for an annual revenue of at least sh70b annually, wouldn’t you have a truly competitive process to select the best possible business manager for the job?

As it is now the university’s CEOs in recent memory have been doctors, computer scientists, chemists, biologists, lawyers, all upstanding gentlemen and a lady, but none a business manager.

That is what Makerere and other public universities need, business managers, people who can take the raw input of youth, capital and the assets the university is endowed with and efficiently graduate productive members of society.

"It is a crying shame that Makerere still gets into fights about money with the staff and students, given the combination of the aforementioned brain power on the hill and the assets under their stewardship....

Nowhere in the world do university students pay the full cost of their education. A clever use of fundraising efforts, income from endowment funds and some state contribution manage to bridge the deficit between student fees and the real cost of education.

It was shocking to learn that student fees have not been increased at Makerere for the last 13 years! At the bare minimum there should be some allowance for inflation. This smacks of cheap populism ignoring good economic sense and digging a deeper hole.

Government has a lot to answer for the chaos at the university. The popular move to open up university education to a wider public, while failing to increase investment in line with the increased enrollment is at the heart of the current crisis.

Makerere is a shadow of its former self, its crumbling halls of residence are testament to this. And how is it that no new hall of residence has been added to its portfolio since CCE was was established in 1982.

This continued failure will force the government to make unwanted decisions. A reality that increases with every day.

On the one hand they maybe forced to close the university all together because it can’t continue to carry it. It may be cheaper to pay fees for students to other universities than pretend to run Makerere. Or to privatize the university, as a going concern, which may invariably lead to a cut back on student numbers but of a better quality.

Neither of the two options are palatable.

Basic education is important for an industrial economy, but tertiary education is critical for the fourth Industrial revolution, where better skilled workers than the automatons of the industrial age will be required.

Government has to make some hard decisions. To divest itself of its universities or commit significantly more resources – financial and managerial, towards university education. Maintaining the status quo is just postponing a major crisis.

Must Read

BOOK REVIEW: MUSEVENI'S UGANDA; A LEGACY FOR THE AGES

The House that Museveni Built: How Yoweri Museveni’s Vision Continues to Shape Uganda By Paul Busharizi  On sale HERE on Amazon (e-book...