Showing posts with label Kenya. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Kenya. Show all posts

Monday, October 5, 2026

AFRICA HAS TOO MANY RICH MEN AND TOO FEW CAPITALISTS

On Wednesday, Aliko Dangote stood in Lamu, Kenya, alongside African leaders and broke ground on a $16 billion oil refinery. The proposed plant will process 700,000 barrels of crude a day, include a 1,000MW power plant and, if completed as planned, rank among the largest refineries in the world.

Think about that.

Sixteen billion dollars. One African businessman. One African project.

That is why I have long argued that Dangote is a godsend for this continent.

Not because billionaires are saints—the Lamu project already faces legitimate land and environmental questions. But because he represents something Africa has in desperately short supply: indigenous capital willing to make bets at continental scale.

Countries are only as viable as their private sectors.

Governments can publish Vision 2040s and industrial policies. Eventually somebody has to write a cheque, build the factory, hire engineers, organise supply chains and wait years for a return.

Businesses, not governments, create wealth, jobs and goods and services. The role of government is to create an economic and legal environment in which more of those businesses can emerge and grow. We have more examples than I have space in this column to list the failed government businesses even in this NRM administration.

For years this column has argued that Africa is not poor. It is a deep-value play whose people, minerals, land and markets are consistently undervalued by bad politics, weak business skills and foreign risk models.

"Foreign capital sees political risk, currency risk, infrastructure gaps and regulatory uncertainty.

The spreadsheet says: run.

Dangote sees the same risks, but he has skin in the game...

That distinction matters. In 2024, writing about Uganda’s infrastructure financing, I argued that local investors often have a more nuanced understanding of African risk. What looks impossible from a London boardroom may be manageable if you understand the politics, people and terrain.

Dangote is that thesis on steroids.

There is another part of the story we underestimate. His commercial software is multigenerational. His great-grandfather, Alhassan Dantata, was among West Africa’s wealthiest traders. Dangote did not start at zero.

But the inheritance was more than money.

It was software.

How to judge risk. Negotiate. Preserve capital. Talk to bankers. Work through government. Reinvest. Survive reversals. Think in decades.

Wealth may be built in one generation and squandered by the third, but Dangote had flipped the script. Each generation appears to have built on what came before.

"That accumulated commercial intelligence now sits on top of a balance sheet large enough to underwrite ventures that would terrify most African governments—or put enough equity on the table for international money men to take notice.

He also straddles two worlds. He speaks the language of international capital—project finance, technical partners, equity, listings and return on capital, while navigating African governments, bureaucracies and the patronage systems surrounding large projects.

That brings us to an uncomfortable point.

Government support for big business is not automatically corruption.

I argued in 2020 that concessions can stimulate development if they back credible businesses, measurable outcomes and strategic industries. The problem is that support is too often handed to connected individuals with neither the competence nor intention to build anything.

The answer is not to stop backing winners.

It is to stop backing cronies.

Asia understood this better. Its governments helped create industrial champions, but eventually those champions had to export, compete and conquer markets. Africa too often protects rent-seekers instead of builders.

Dangote’s greatest achievement may therefore not be cement, fertiliser or even oil.

It may be confidence.

His Lagos refinery shattered a psychological ceiling. Projects of that scale were supposed to be built by multinationals, Gulf sovereigns or Chinese state companies. An African industrialist was supposed to trade, import, distribute and perhaps put up a respectable factory.

Dangote decided otherwise.

Now he is trying to reproduce the model in East Africa.

Success markets itself. Once investors see Africans successfully executing projects at this scale, they begin imagining steel mills, fertiliser plants, rail corridors and other mega-projects. Capital compounds, but confidence compounds too.

Africa therefore needs more Dangotes.

Not more rich men.

There is a difference.

A rich man wants to show that he has money. A capitalist wants to deploy money so it comes back with friends.

"A rich man measures success in VXs, mansions and little brown girls in tow. A capitalist measures it in productive assets, cashflows, factories and return on capital...

One consumes wealth.

The other reproduces it.

The tragedy of Africa is not that we have too many billionaires. It is that we have too few people whose ambitions have graduated from consumption to production and from national markets to continental ones.

Our governments should align development ambitions with indigenous capital while creating the conditions for larger African balance sheets: predictable policy, property rights, capital markets, patient finance and integrated regional markets.

Dangote will make enormous amounts of money if Lamu works.

Good.

If his billions come alongside jobs, skills, taxes, suppliers, infrastructure and cheaper energy, that is not a contradiction.

That is the bargain.

Capital makes money. Citizens live better.

"Our real failure would be to meet here again in 30 years and discover that Africa still has only one Dangote...

Saturday, September 26, 2026

NSSF’S 22.53%: WHEN COMPOUNDING STARTS TO LOOK LIKE MAGIC

On Thursday night, millions of Ugandans with savings at the National Social Security Fund went to bed considerably richer than they had woken up.

The Fund declared an interest rate of 22.53 percent for the year ended June 2026, the highest in its 40-year history. In money terms, Shs5.44 trillion will be credited to members’ accounts.

For perspective, last year the Fund paid 13.5 percent. Average inflation during the year was about 3.3 percent, meaning members earned a real return of about 19 percentage points. Better still, over the last decade NSSF has credited members with returns averaging about 12.6 percent annually. (NSSF Integrated Report 2026)

That is where the real story begins.

We tend to get excited by spectacular years and ignore the boring years that made them possible. But wealth is rarely built in dramatic bursts. It is built by putting money away, earning a return, reinvesting that return and resisting the temptation to interrupt the process.

NSSF may be Uganda’s biggest practical demonstration of compounding.

Its assets have grown from around Shs5.6 trillion in 2015 to Shs32.87 trillion today. In just the last year, the balance sheet grew 26 percent from Shs26 trillion. (NSSF Integrated Report 2026)

A billion shillings starts with one shilling. The mighty tree starts as a seedling. The trick is staying on the compounding curve long enough for the numbers to begin looking ridiculous.

NSSF’s numbers are beginning to look ridiculous.

Total income jumped 85 percent to Shs6.51 trillion. Contributions increased to Shs2.42 trillion while benefits paid rose to Shs1.55 trillion. 

But this year also offers another important lesson in investing: diversification requires patience.

NSSF has substantial investments outside Uganda. That exposes it not only to share-price movements but to currencies.

We saw the ugly side of that in 2022/23, when depreciation of regional currencies, particularly the Kenya shilling, left the Fund nursing foreign-exchange losses of about Shs1.05 trillion. Last year the strengthening Uganda shilling again worked against NSSF, producing forex losses of about Shs274 billion, even as regional stockmarkets performed reasonably well.

This year the pendulum swung the other way.

Currency movements added about Shs173 billion to the Fund’s income. But the real fireworks came from regional equities.

Shares, although only about 18 percent of the portfolio, generated roughly 43 percent of total income

. NSSF’s equity portfolio returned an astonishing 60.8 percent, compared with 25.2 percent the previous year, as banks and telecom shares across East Africa rallied strongly. Holdings including CRDB, NMB, MTN, Airtel and KCB recorded significant gains. 

There is a wonderful investing lesson here.

Had NSSF panicked when regional currencies collapsed and markets went against it, sold everything and retreated home, members might never have enjoyed this year’s upside.

Markets move. Currencies move. Yesterday’s dog can become tomorrow’s star.

A long-term investor does not judge an investment strategy on one bad year—or one spectacular one.

Which brings us to the future.

NSSF has revised its Vision 2035 asset target from Shs50 trillion to Shs80 trillion

, while seeking to expand social-security coverage to about 15 million people. That means the informal economy—boda riders, farmers, traders and millions of self-employed Ugandans—will increasingly become central to the Fund’s growth...

But getting to Shs80 trillion creates another problem: where do you put all that money?

Today about three-quarters of the portfolio is in fixed income. Government securities have served NSSF exceedingly well, providing predictable cashflows and attractive yields.

But an Shs80 trillion Fund cannot just keep buying government bonds forever.

Increasingly, NSSF will have to look at infrastructure, private equity, businesses, regional markets and other long-term assets. With scale comes the possibility of becoming one of the most important pools of patient capital in East Africa.

And with that opportunity comes danger.

"NSSF is not a development bank. Members’ savings cannot become a convenient pot for every politically attractive road, hotel or factory. Every investment must pass one overriding test: does the expected risk-adjusted return justify putting workers’ retirement savings into it?

Nobody should expect 22.53 percent every year.

Interest rates will fall. Stockmarkets will retreat. The shilling will strengthen and weaken. Some years regional investments will deliver spectacular gains; in others currency translation alone may wipe hundreds of billions off their Ugandan-shilling value.

That is investing.

The bigger lesson from Thursday night is therefore not really 22.53 percent.

It is what happens when capital is accumulated, diversified, professionally invested and allowed to compound for decades.

Forty years of contributions and reinvestment have created an institution capable of crediting Shs5.44 trillion to its members in one year.

For the individual wealth creator, the instruction could hardly be clearer:

"Start where you are. Invest what you can. Diversify. Reinvest the harvest. And whatever you do, try not to interrupt the compounding...

Given enough time, boring can become spectacular.

Wednesday, October 15, 2025

OBITUARY: RAILA ODINGA: THE PERENNIAL NEARLY MAN OF KENYAN POLITICS

When the news broke that Raila Amolo Odinga had died in India on the morning of October 15, 2025, it was as if Kenya exhaled — not in relief, but in recognition. A chapter that had refused to close for nearly half a century had finally done so, not through concession or defeat, but through death. The man who had stood at the threshold of power more times than any other in Kenya’s history — and perhaps in Africa’s post-independence politics — was gone.

For decades, Raila had been the perennial nearly man of Kenyan politics: the revolutionary who came close, the reformer who redefined the system yet was never fully embraced by it, the man who helped make presidents but never quite became one. His career was a chronicle of near-victories and unfinished revolutions — an unending duel with destiny that both ennobled and exhausted him.

The Making of a Contrarian

Born in 1945, the son of Jaramogi Oginga Odinga, Kenya’s first Vice President, Raila inherited not wealth but a legacy of dissent. His father had famously turned his back on Jomo Kenyatta’s administration, accusing it of betraying the promises of independence. The young Raila absorbed that oppositional spirit like mother’s milk.

After studying engineering in East Germany — where socialism, worker solidarity and the architecture of the state fascinated him — Raila returned home with both technical training and ideological conviction. His engineering mind would later show in his politics: pragmatic, systematic, sometimes coldly analytical. But in a political culture driven by tribe and charisma, his rationalism was often his undoing.

He entered politics in the late 1970s, at a time when Daniel arap Moi’s one-party state brooked no dissent. Raila’s agitation for multiparty democracy saw him jailed, tortured and isolated. Yet, like the phoenix he admired, he always re-emerged. Each time, leaner, shrewder — and a little more calculating.

The Politics of Almost

Raila’s story is written in the grammar of almosts.
He almost toppled the one-party state. He almost became president. He almost dismantled the culture of impunity.
But each “almost” came with a paradoxical triumph — because in trying, he shifted the ground beneath Kenyan politics.

In 1997, he ran for president for the first time and came third — but cemented himself as a national figure. In 2002, he famously led the “Kibaki Tosha” movement, uniting the opposition behind Mwai Kibaki. That coalition ended 24 years of Moi rule — yet Raila was soon alienated by the same power he helped deliver.

In 2007, he came closer than ever. The polls were disputed, the results contested, and Kenya plunged into bloodshed. The subsequent peace deal made him Prime Minister, a title that acknowledged his legitimacy but denied him the presidency he believed he had earned.

In 2013 and again in 2017, he ran, rallied millions, and lost — narrowly, contentiously. His refusal to concede earned him admirers for courage and critics for obstinacy. When he was sworn in as the “People’s President” in 2018 in a mock ceremony, it was both defiance and symbolism — an act of protest against an establishment that he believed had stolen his destiny.

Even his handshake with Uhuru Kenyatta that same year — a moment meant to heal the nation — became another “almost.” It promised unity but fractured his opposition base. To his supporters, he had matured into a statesman. To his detractors, he had capitulated.

The Weight of History

Raila’s life was a bridge between Kenya’s liberation generation and its democratic awakening. His father fought colonialism; Raila fought its post-independence mutations — authoritarianism, corruption, ethnic patronage. Yet like many reformers who live long enough, he began to resemble the system he had sought to change.

By the time he sought the African Union Commission chairmanship in 2024, the firebrand had become a global elder, respected abroad even as his domestic star dimmed. His rhetoric softened, his edges rounded by time, but the central tragedy remained: Kenya loved Raila but did not trust him enough to make him president.

Some said it was tribal arithmetic — the Luo vote could never outnumber the Kikuyu-Kalenjin blocs that alternated power. Others said it was his temperament: a man too radical for the cautious middle. But perhaps it was simpler — Raila was the conscience of the republic, and conscience rarely wins elections.

The Nearness of Greatness

To call him “the nearly man” is not an insult but a description of the arc of his life — one that shadowed Kenya’s journey from colonialism to capitalism, from dictatorship to democracy. He stood for ideas that were often ahead of his time: devolution, electoral justice, energy reform, transparency. Yet he was forever caught between vision and viability.

His relationship with power was intimate but incomplete — he was always in its corridors, seldom in its throne room. And yet, in a deeper sense, he was Kenya’s political axis. Every presidency of the last four decades was shaped, challenged, or legitimized in response to him. His defeats defined others’ victories. His persistence gave Kenya its democratic pulse.

Like Sisyphus, he kept rolling the boulder of reform up the mountain, only to watch it tumble back down. But each time, the mountain moved a little.

The Man Behind the Myth

Behind the rhetoric and rallies was a man of surprising tenderness. He loved literature and reggae, football and debate. His marriage to Ida Odinga was a partnership forged in the fires of prison, exile and protest. He doted on his children, especially his late son Fidel, whose death in 2015 marked him deeply.

Raila had a mischievous humour and a gift for reinvention. He could command a rally with thunder and, minutes later, trade jokes in Dholuo with market women. He relished confrontation but valued loyalty. In public life, he carried the gravitas of a prophet; in private, he could be disarmingly ordinary — fond of tea, storytelling and long, unhurried conversations about the destiny of nations.

The Final Campaign

In death, Raila finally accomplished what eluded him in life — a unanimous Kenya. For once, all sides grieved him without reservation. His supporters mourned their unfulfilled dream; his rivals honoured an adversary who dignified politics by his presence.

His passing forces a reckoning: that Kenya’s democracy, though maturing, still owes a debt to those who never quite arrived but cleared the path for others.

Raila Odinga’s life invites us to measure success not only by the offices we hold but by the ideas that outlive us. He never became president, but he helped make Kenya more democratic, more self-aware, more restless for justice.

In that sense, the nearly man may, in the end, have come closest of all.

“History is not written by those who win,” he once told a crowd in Kisumu. “It is written by those who endure.”

Raila Odinga endured — and in doing so, etched his name into the very idea of Kenya.

May the man who almost became president rest as a patriot who already became immortal.

Monday, May 27, 2024

ELECTRICITY AS AN EXPORT? WHO WOULD HAVE THOUGHT

That year we were the brightest of the brightest. The instructors set us a quiz to determine our knowledge of country.

The one question I will never forget was “What are Uganda’s cash crops?” Chicken feed for the 1,000 of us seated on the floor of the grass thatched classroom. Coffee, tea, cotton. What about maize, they asked. And cassava? And beans? Aren’t they cash crops?

Credit to us, we all fell silent as we let these new “facts” register, rather than protest and make bigger fools of ourselves.

All our school lives, 13 years up to that point, we had parroted in exam after exam, coffee, tea and cotton as Uganda’s cash crops.

Fast forward to 1997. I found myself on the commodities trading floor of HSBC bank In London, where they told me $150b in transactions passed through that room daily, Uganda’s GDP at the time was $6b, and I happened upon a research note that said coffee we would fall below 50 percent of the country’s total exports by the turn of the century.

That was a mind bending proposition, because in that year coffee exports accounted for six in every $10 of our exports, down from 90 percent in 1986.

"In today’s Uganda where coffee exports not only account for 30 percent of export value, but the sale of the aromatic bean has been overtaken by gold exports, that’s not news. It was at the time.

A quarter century later and the brightest of the brightest of our youth are probably due for another mind bending moment.

In April, the Kenyan media reported that their imports of power had hit an all-time high in the first quarter of the year. They imported 408.78 gigawatthours (GWh) up 42 percent from the same period last year. The source of their imports? Uganda and Ethiopia.

Uganda Electricity Transmission Company Ltd (UETCL) reports exports of electricity were back to pre-covid levels at $44m (sh170b) last year, small when seen against total receipts of $5b but significant none the less. Going by the growth trajectory of the last four years this number is set to double by 2028.

We have always exported power to Kenya but with new generation capacity we are exporting more and more, especially now we are a member of the East Africa Power Pool (EAPP), which is connecting power generators to the region so power can be transmitted wherever it is needed in the region.

Trade in electricity within the EAPP has grown six fold to 3400 GWh annually since 2005 when it was begun.

So it makes sense to increase our generation capacity – one study showed we have at least 4000 MW of hydroelectric power potential, but also invest more in the high voltage transmission lines required to evacuate the power.

Currently lines from Gulu-Nebbi-Arua, Kabale-Mirama and Masaka-Mbarara are in the works. As long as our electricity sector is efficient, so as to ensure demand for our power abroad, the enormous power needs locally and regionally would make such investments no brainers.

It will not help that projects, which should ordinarily take six years to develop take more than a decade 

-- see Karuma dam, as these delays are an additional cost that would price us out of the market. We are not big players, seeing by the total trade in power in the region of 3400Gwh versus our exports last year of 485 GWh. Also because the region has surplus of power generation capacity – 90,000 MW versus peak demand of 54,000 MW, it is a buyers’ market, meaning no one will take our power if it is not competitively priced.

Producing for export means we are subjecting ourselves to more exacting standards than we tolerate at home. Our trading partners do not expect frequent power outages, brown outs and power surges. They will probably sue us for such infringements unlike our pliant locals.

 Exporting power should be an exciting thing, if only because it could serve as the new trick question for our pre-university youth, something like “Which of our exports does not go out by road, rail or air?”

 


Tuesday, February 6, 2024

UGANDA’S RECORD FDI AND THE MAN ON THE STREET

In November audit firm Ernst & Young (E&Y) released a report on Africa’s economic prospects.

"In the report “Pivot to growth” E&Y reported that Uganda attracted a record $10b in foreign direct investment in 2022 or seven in every ten dollars of FDI that came into East Africa that year....

This was driven by projects in the oil & gas sector.

The news left the man on the street scratch his head at how come he never saw this money.

The confusion comes from our not understanding how FDI is reported and secondly, how such monies when they do come, trickle down to the everyday man.

Reading the report one realises that when they talk of $10b in FDI booked, they are reporting the monies committed for a project. So in our case for example, our share of the $10b East African Crude Pipeline (EACOP)for which final investment decision was reached in  2022 would be included in this number.

The funds of course will not arrive in one lumpsum but will mostly be parceled out over the duration of the project.

Why we did not see immediate improvement in the contents of our pockets is largely a function of what the project will need or buy locally.

The planning, design, plant and machinery will be  bought abroad and paid for there but are factored in as project costs. Foreign contractors may very well be paid in  to their accounts at home.

Local contractors, suppliers, hospitality and service providers are beginning to smell the money.

But as we all know there is no one as quiet as a man who has been paid. The loud ones are the one who are not in the slip stream of the money...

In years after commercial viability of our oil finds was determined in 2006, government has written into law what sectors of the industries servicing the oil & gas sector can be ringfenced for Ugandans. These were mostly food, hospitality, security, logistics and other low capital intensive sectors.

So if you are a friend, relative or business partners of the local businessmen who have already seen some contracts you are not complaining.

But also while the oil & gas sector may very well effect some major changes in the greater scheme of things our 200,000 barrels per day at full capacity, is really not much to write home about.

Nigeria last year averaged 1.35 million barrels per day, Angola came in second at 1.1 million barrels per day and Algeria at 908,000 barrels per day.

That being said businessmen are reporting that they are beginning to feel an uptick in demand, starting the middle of last year and one may imagine some trickle down is beginning to show its head.

The relative stability of the Uganda shilling which traded in a a narrow band of sh3750 – sh3850  may also indicate that some of that oil money is already coming and supporting the shilling.

Kenya across the border saw its currency cross the sh160 to the dollar mark before Christmas, a trend that continued into January. Some of the reasons were falling commodity prices and a flight for the exit on indications our eastern neighbour is set to default on some key international loans.

Whether you will earn from the oil & gas sector or not will depend on how you are positioned. As a worker the industry has stringent accreditation standards that have to met before they can look your way, for contractors and suppliers the same.

"The expectation is that at least $20b will spent until first oil in 2025 and so it may not be late to position oneself to draw from the oil wells...

The money will not come dripping with oil and easily recognisable as coming from the sector, but it will come.

Many have been called to partake  but few will be chosen.



Tuesday, January 23, 2024

A RETURN TO SAPS IS A REAL POSSIBILITY

In his latest report the Audit General drew a painful picture of how our domestic arrears are doubling every five years with no effective action to slow down this accumulation or pay them off.

The Auditor General John Muwanga in his report of the year that ended in June 2023 said domestic arrears continued to mount by 16 percent annually, inexplicably and illegally.

“Some accounting offices are concealing domestic arrears and paying for arrears which previously were not disclosed nor budgeted for,” Muwanga reported.

“In other instances, the arrears disclosed are not properly supported by evidence of goods or a service. I further observed that some entities have entered in to multi-year commitments without parliamentary approval.”

In simple English officers are paying for ghost products and services, hiding legitimate claims on government while paying the fictitious ones and committing government to debts without proper approvals.

The net effect of this, is that what government owes to suppliers has nearly tripled to sh10.5trillion in 2022/23 from sh3.335 trillion in 2018/19, with no corresponding growth in revenues. During the same period URA collections grew by just over 50 percent to sh25.2trillion from sh16.6trillion. Just by that simple calculation it is inconceivable that government will ever fully pay these domestic arrears.

The worst offenders are Kampala Capital City Authority (KCCA) who in the last year’s domestic arrears jumped almost tenfold, followed by the works ministry, prisons and the finance ministry. That is ironic because the finance ministry is supposed to be overseeing and implementing the discipline around accumulating domestic arrears.

This is a scary situation than is being acknowledged by the government.

So I have a friend who does business with government. They owe him a few billion shillings for work that has been done and certified. His business is on its knees because between government not paying him, URA is baying for his blood, as is his bank. To survive he has been forced to regress into informality. He has adopted two sets of books, cut back on his official payroll and basically insists on being paid in cash and not through the formal financial system.

It does not take a rocket scientist to see what will happen if his methods are replicated across hundreds or even thousands of companies.

URA will huff and puff but will find little love in the private sector. That is not a threat but a promise.

It is so bad, that many banks are refusing to discount government invoices. Previously if a business man won a deal he could take an invoice he had made to government and borrow against it in the bank. Now banks don’t want to touch that “counterfeit” paper with a ten-foot pole. Businesses are slowly grinding to a halt.

This is an unsustainable situation. Our taxes come from private companies and individuals. With businesses struggling they will close down altogether costing jobs in the companies and among its suppliers.

What the Auditor General was describing up there was corruption in very many words. Despite a policy and new blood in the ministry the interest groups around this racket are so firmly entrenched they can openly defy Ramathan Goobi’s best efforts to bring some sanity to the system. Isn’t it just a matter of time before he throws up his hands in defeat or joins them anyway?

"There is even a scarier scenario.  That these interest groups that are a law unto themselves, have actually captured the state...

Ebola is particularly dangerous parasite because it feeds off the host and when they die abandon them for a new host. When it is feeding off the host it has no thought of coexistence, it just feeds off the host in disregard of the hosts continued life.

That is what the Auditor General is reporting is happening in the Uganda government. That the corrupt are feeding off the state without regard for whether it will continue to exist. In fact when every one else is tightening their belts, these leeches are accelerating their eating and to hell with everything.

This cannot end well, especially if good people decide to join in the plunder.

While it may sound drastic you just have to look across the border to Kenya to see what happens when a rapacious clique takes over the state and bend it to their own over the national intersts. For all intents and purposes, they are going back to Structral Adjustment Programme (SAP) -- raising taxes, cutting subsidies and privatizing public enterprises to qualify for much needed cash.

All this because revenue inflows have long been surpassed by government expenditure. If corruption was tackled decisively you would be shocked how dramatically government expenses would collapse.

And this is not just macroeconomics. As a proxy of economic activity mobile money transactions in Kenya last year for the first time in 17 years. The small man is feeling the pain in a very real way.

God forbid that we find ourselves back in SAPs because of our indiscipline. But how improbable is that given what we know?


Tuesday, January 2, 2024

KENYA’S CAUTIONARY TALE FOR UGANDA

My driver Stephen reflected the attitude of many Kenyans to the current rise in the cost of living in our eastern neighbour. He thought it had long gotten out of hand and could cause instability in the region’s biggest economy.

"In 2023 since the ascendance to the top job by President William Ruto, Kenyans have seen their cost of living soaring with the removal of fuel subsidies, increases in consumption taxes and fall of the Kenyan shilling to historical lows....

The Kenya shilling crossed the sh150 mark against the US dollar in October and peaked at kShs156 before Christmas.

But these are just the symptoms of even more fundamental weakness in the economy.

For example, that the export receipts were down in the 12 months up to October despite the shilling depreciating 19 percent during the period. A weaker shilling should see higher export earnings in Kenya shillings even if they just exported the same amount of goods as a comparable period in the past. The fact that export earnings suggests that the economies productivity is also falling.

It could not have come at a worse time. Next year the $2b Eurobond principle comes due at the end of June and they need all the hard currency they can lay their hands on.

So, it makes sense that the government is scrambling every which way it can to raise these funds, including overtures to the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to ease the pain.

The weakening shilling of course not helping matters as the shillings weakening added Ksh810b (sh19trillion) in interest payments in the year to October according to the Central Bank of Kenya (CBK).

How did they come to this? An ambitious infrastructure expansion first during the Mwai Kibaki presidency, which paved way for a questionable expansion drive during the time of Uhuru Kenyatta era, mostly funded by debt, is coming back to bite.

There are questions whether the $2b Eurobond, contracted in 2014, was actually used for its intended purpose, with reports that the proceeds found their way into private pockets.

Few can argue with paying for infrastructure development with debt. Infrastructure should ease doing business in an economy, leading to more taxes making it affordable to pay off the debt. But if the infrastructure developed does not come with an attendant increase in economic activity, then trouble begins.

The ambitious Standard Gauge Railway (SGR) which cost $3.6b and whose loan grace period expired in 2021 is putting great strain on the Kenya treasury, especially since revenues from the SGR operations have not yet caught up with costs.

Industry watchers have said the only way the project can have a chance of viability is if it is linked to Kampala and its rich hinterland. That has not happened as the project is in limbo, having stopped in Naivasha.

There are other things that are conspiring to stress the Kenyan economy – corruption being at the top, and now the bitter pill of economic restructuring has become inevitable.

"We were there in the 1980s and 1990s when revenues were anemic and loans were falling due left right and center. Increased taxes and liberalization of the economy helped us pull out, but the pain still traumatizes a generation....

We hear similar noises in Kenya from what was here then, with the arm chair commentators complaining that the economic moves the government is taking – raising taxes and restructuring the economy, were a sell out to the west.

The net sum of this contrary view, is that the Kenya government should continue with business as usual and somehow things will sort themselves out.

This kicking the tin down the road prescription was tried by the Uhuru government and means the pain of restructuring will be that more painful.

Kenya unlike us in the 1990s have a robust commercial sector and even if there are reports of massive capital flight, one should expect they will come through eventually. The key is the government, does it have the cojones to do what is needed to do or will it only tweak around the edges and hope for the best?

Do the necessary maybe politically expensive, but if they get down to it now maybe by the time of the next election in 2028, the economic pressures will have eased with the greater efficiencies created and the William Ruto adminstration may very well have been forgiven by then.

The current Uganda government cash squeeze, a result of a growing debt servicing bill – it jumped 50 percent to $722m in 2022 from $480m in 2021 and growing, is cause for concern. Thankfully our revenues continue to grow as do our export receipts. The hope is these will continue to grow despite the strain on the private sector, which government owes sh8trillion and shows little willingness to settle – in this budget sh200b was provided towards retiring this debt, but maybe a case of us burying our heads in the sand.

With our politics in transition, it is unlikely that the government can take the hard decisions, like it did in the 1990s to get the economy back on track. The trick is to not to dig ourselves into that hole or take the initiative in cutting down the cost of our public administration before someone comes along and forces us to do it.

Happy New Year!

 


Tuesday, December 5, 2023

KENYA PRIVATISATION, BETTER LATE THAN NEVER

Last week Kenya’s President William Ruto announced his government would be privatising 35 state owned companies.

To that end, a new law  been enacted that brings into force an agency to carry out the exercise without bureaucratic interference.

The naysayers of course are up in arms, seeing this as an International Monetary Fund (IMF) plot to take Kenyan assets on the cheap.

Even if that is true no one is asking how Kenya came into a situation that the IMF would dictate to it.

"The IMF is like the lender of last resort. When no one else will touch you with  a 100-foot poll the IMF is the one you go to. But they are not a charitable organisation, their money has a cost.

Normally others will not lend to you, because the probability is high you will not be able to repay them.

So the IMF may insist on more efficiency in the economy and the easiest thing is to flog all the deadweight companies that are sucking more out of the government than they are paying back in taxes and dividends.

Greater efficiency in the economy will make the IMF redundant, as the country will be able to go to the open market to borrow funds.

Privatisation can take many forms, selling the company as a going concern or liquidating it all together – selling the assets and paying off the liabilities.

In the last incidence the company maybe beyond salvage – up to its eyeballs in debt, in need of major recapitalisation and in a dying industry, in which case it may not make business sense to try and keep it going.

But if the company is to be sold as a going concern one can expect that the labour force will be cut (tribalism and nepotism are never an efficient recruiting mechanism), minimum efficiencies achieved, while replacing obsolete machinery before they may think about beefing up staff numbers again.

The Uganda experience shows that the labour force eventually surpasses the original numbers before privatisation. The only thing is that it is not all those who are retrenched that regain their old jobs.

"The main aim is not to raise money but to create greater efficiency in the economy...

Kenya has a fairly robust stock exchange on which some of these companies can be offloaded – if they have sound management and strong balance sheets, but chances are they will be sold to investors directly.

The critics will say that since many of these companies will be snapped up by foreign investors it amounts to colonialism via the back door.

It would be ideal that local businessmen buy the companies. But often what happens is that it is cronies of the political elite who “buy” these companies, who often can not raise capital to revamp them and end up selling them anyway, to foreign investors at multiples of the price they bought it at.

The ordinary citizen  is often conned into thinking it is better to sell to our own, not knowing they are facilitating crony capitalism with they being the eventual loser. They lose because efficiencies are not created that would see a wide supply of goods or services.

Kenyan indigenous capital would have a better chance of participating in the up coming privatisation, because not only are they wealthier but also because they know how to mobilise resources in groups. They have longer experience in SACCOS and investment groups than we do or did in the 1990s, when our privatisation process was taking off.

In the final analysis the man on the street wants better goods and services at a fair price, they really don’t care who owns the company.

In theb 1990s Russia, still hung up on their socialist dogma, privatised many of their companies by giving shares to the workers. The workers ended yup selling their shares to a few connected Russians who are today’s oligarchs, fabulously wealthy people (all men) and the workers’ plight is worse off than it was under communism, especially since expected efficiencies did not turn up in the economy. And also because they took the money from these companies to buy assets abroad, like Chelsea FC.

But if ownership is such a big deal, the Kenya government should make listing on the Nairobi Stock Exchange (NSE) within a certain time frame as a condition of sale. No gentleman’s agreement as happened here, with the eventual owners not acting as gentlemen eventually.

"The powerful interest groups in Kenya that have resisted the privatisation of companies have finally run out of runway. These companies should have been privatised 20 years or so ago. But the economic realities have dictated that  they have to go now.

Dictated because the short term suffering from privatisation can be politically costly. Ruto did not come to this decision with out the economic reality staring in the face. He needs to offload as much excess baggage on the national purse strings, if he is to have ha lf a chance of getting the Kenya economy back on track.

Again we bring such hard decisions on ourselves. If these companies were well run and making contributions to the treasury the case for their sale would be hard to sustain.

But no, people are not asking the major question, who put us in this position?

 

Tuesday, October 17, 2023

IS IT POSSIBLE FOR SMOKE WITHOUT FIRE?

MPs are up in arms at what they see as an unfair bailout of thermal power generator Electromaxx, controlled by businessman Patrick Bitature.

They claim government has paid $13m (sh48b) for the Tororo 90MW thermal power plant, particularly annoying prospect when government is in the throes of a cash squeeze.

Such stories serve to score cheap points against the government to the detriment of economic players, until they are put under a microscope.

While the politicians will not let the facts get in the way of a good story, the truth will set us free.

Electromaxx has a Power Purchase Agreement (PPA) to produce power at the thermal power plant.  The plant uses Heavy Fuel Oil (HFO) to generate power which is fed into the grid via the substation in Tororo.

The PPA stipulates the generators obligations and government’s as well, which among other things outlines how they will pay for power. We will not get bogged down in the details of the PPA but let us just say that government owes Electromaxx millions of dollars in back payments under the agreement.

To back track a bit. To build a plant of that magnitude – it was reported to have cost $60m (sh200b) to set up, no one, fishes in their pocket to pay for the massive civil works, the generators and the installation. You borrow the money from the bank. The loan it is envisaged will be paid serviced using the money you will get from generating power according to the contract.

So, when government does not pay you as planned, inevitably you are going to come under the gun, especially from your creditors – not only the banks but your suppliers as well.

As a way to extricate themselves from this unfortunate situation, it was agreed that government takes the plant off Electromaxx hands.

The politicians argue that why should such a deal be done when we have hydropower surplus. Thermal power plants are often used as back up capacity, if you have them and don’t need them now you keep them available for the time when they are needed.

While we enjoy relatively consistent power now, most of our power comes from hydro power, which can be affected by the vagaries of nature and climate change. A drop in water levels or damage to one plant or the other – all events we have witnessed in the last few years, can cause the grid to trip and throw us into darkness. Also in the recent past vandalism of transmission lines have cut off parts of Uganda off the grid. It was envisaged that the Tororo plant will serve a s a stop gap measure to sustain power in the Tororo industrial area, eastern Uganda and for power exports to Kenya.

There is an Energy Policy, drawn up in 2018 that recognizes this risk. In the policy it is required that the energy generation mix includes 10 percent thermal power, among more than one plant.

 So, it makes sense for government to control the Tororo plant as it does the Namanve plant which it took over after operator Jakobsen Elektromaxx concession came to a close last year.

I would imagine the Electromaxx owners would have been loved to paid a nice bulk figure, but government’s cash situation is that that is not possible.

So, the tow parties have agreed that government will take over the Tororo plant, but maintain Electromaxx as the operators for the next five years, allowing them to get paid over that time.

Essentially, they have changed the agreement from Build Operate & Own (BOO) to a Build Operate & Transfer (BOT) arrangement, which is a fundamental change in the agreement which would change the nature of the PPA.

Meanwhile the millions of dollars government owes to Electromaxx remain outstanding, which negotiations remain ongoing.

Two things stand out for me in this whole sorry saga. It is prudent for a country, which has aspirations for industrialization to have a steady supply of power. Contracts especially export contracts, can not go begging because you had power outages. The penalties for such can bring down whole industries. So inbuilt redundancy in the network is prudent. Ofcourse one can argue that right now we are running surplus generation capacity but when more than 90 percent of your generation capacity is hydropower, even that surplus is at risk.

Secondly, the backstory to this is that it is extremely difficult do business with government. As at the last budget reading government had domestic arrears of sh8trillion, for which they have provided sh200b, isn’t it any surprise that the gains of the last 30 years are not being felt equitably around the population?


Tuesday, October 10, 2023

DO NOT MESS WITH THE LAWS OF SUPPLY AND DEMAND

It was interesting how the problems surrounding Kenya’s fuel pump prices have gone largely uncovered in the Uganda press.

Ahead of the last election the government of Uhuru Kenyatta, in a populist move to win votes for Raila Odinga, decided to hold the fuel prices at a certain level. Pump prices were rising very fast.

At the time the war in Ukraine and the hangover from the Covid lockdown, which had disrupted global supply chains, was pushing up pump prices all around the world.

Nairobi decided that they would pay the oil companies for any cost incurred above the price they had fixed.

There were snide remarks from our side of the border, with people saying that that is how real governments work to cushion their people from bad things. I was not one of them and in fact predicted in this column that it would end in tears. 

It is a common saying in the market that the market will remain irrational longer than you can be liquid...

It was not long before government was reneging on the deal or rather, they run out of money to pay the oil companies to hold the price stable.  The oil companies responded by turning off the taps, until their bill was met.

Soon there were fuel lines in Nairobi – but not in Kampala, where government had wisely let the pump prices find their level.

A few weeks ago the Kenya government issued the fuel companies a bond in lieu of cash payment. The bond would ensure a regular payment from government and could be used as collateral for alternative financing, that is if the market trust the Kenya government.

And finally last week it was reported that Kenyans have decided to leave their cars at home as in September fuel consumption had fallen to its lowest level in five years.

There is a famous experiment of about boiling a frog. That if you threw a frog in a pan of boiling water it would jump out immediately, unable to stand the heat. On the other hand if you put the frog in a pan of cold water and continued to heat the pan slowly, it will take longer to feel the heat and jump out.

When you try to hold prices artificially, its like boiling the water before throwing the frog in. When you can no longer hold the subsidy (read the frog has to be put in the pan) the price will jump or fall dramatically, making adjustment all the more painful. Kenyans were shocked when the prices jumped to the real level earlier this year and have responded by parking their cars.

Ugandans on the other hand, while they complained about fuel prices crossing the sh5000 liter mark last year, adjusted to the price adjustments the best way they could, and for a brief moment earlier this year prices dipped below sh5000 again. Of course, no one reported that. Now that they are climbing back up above sh5000 the chattering masses have gone into overdrive.

The naysayers will say that even the more developed economies provide subsidies for certain essential goods and services. Two wrongs don’t make a right and no one talks about the cost of these subsidies...

The trillions of shillings the Kenya government owes the oil companies will come the expense of health and education services, infrastructure development and other public goods, denying the majority of Kenyans the chance to climb the social ladder by improving their living standards.

Interestingly at the heart of every subsidy there are a few connected people who make disproportionate profits from them. So the biggest beneficiaries are not the little man as the politicians would like us to believe.

Our politicians are not stupid. They know the way to tackle market imbalances is by addressing the supply-demand equation. If prices are too high, look to increase supply. If prices are too low, look to increase demand.

The problem of course is that these interventions could take time and not convenient for the politicians. Even when subsidies are used to boost production instead of consumption, they distort the market – pushing legitimate businessmen out and developing interest groups which will fight to sustain the subsidy, regardless of the economic case against it. And the day of reckoning will eventually come around.

We get around this by keeping in my that adhering to the law of supply and demand is least painful remedy. And in the event that we choose to flaunt or ignore it that we will pay the price. But what do the politicians care they will have moved onto the next flavour of the month.

 


Tuesday, March 28, 2023

UPE AND THE FLIGHT FROM POVERTY

Getting out of poverty follows a simple formula.

But first what is poverty? Poverty generally, is the inability to meet your basic needs. The opposite of which is being rich, where you can not only met your basic needs, but have surplus income that comes from your assets.

"The formula of getting out of poverty is to trade value for income and with that income create more value and therefore more income. A virtuous cycle. A simple formula but not easy to execute...

The trick is to have something – a good or service, of value to trade. It is possible to have value and fail to trade it, either because there is no market for it or that the market is not aware of your value, but that’s a discussion for another day.

At the heart of the challenge for most anti-poverty programs is how do you create value and then get it to market, and do this sustainably over time.

The reason you are poorer than the richest man in your town is because he knows something you don’t. What he knows that you don’t, makes him behave in a way that ensures he earns more than you.

So invariably creating value often comes with mindset change.

Last week the education ministry commemorated the 25 years of Universal Primary Education (UPE) program. What started off as a response to a campaign promise by presidential candidate Paul Ssemogerere in  1996, was a good idea that was long overdue. Since then primary enrollment has jumped to  about eight million today from two million in 1996 and seen literacy levels  almost double to 75 percent from 43 percent in 1986.

As suggested above education, which by definition entails a mindset change and therefore creation of value, is a useful first step to lift people out of poverty.

There are questions about the content of our education system, but if one is literate can overcome these shortcomings with continuous learning.

It should come as no surprise that Kenya and Tanzania, which in the case of the former has had bigger enrollments at primary school or in the case of the latter started UPE in 1977 are bigger economies than Uganda. Their literacy levels reflect the earlier adoption of UPE with Kenya at 82 percent and Tanzania 81 percent.

"The thing with such social engineering initiatives is that it takes time to see tangible results, which may discourage people with shorter electoral time spans. But the benefits are there, its just that they may just creep up on you.

What value can you put on being able to communicate in one language all around the country? How much easier is trade? How much easier is it to mobilise populations? How much market do you create when more of us are educated or at least literate?

It’s happening already. While ideally we should be communicating in an indigenous language other than English, you can now go anywhere in the country and manage just fine with English, as most people now have studied English to some basic level. Hopefully with the introduction of Kiswahili at primary school, in another 25 years we should more improved communication around the country.

That being said there is a lot to be done. The education ministry reports that there is no government aided school in 1,617 of the more than 10,000 parishes in the country.

The ministry estimates that it will need sh1.89trillion or about sh1.2b per school to bridge this gap. Apart from questions of value for money there really should not be any hesitation in releasing these funds.

The best investment a nation can make is to invest in its people, and providing education as well as health services should be key.

A country like Singapore with a tenth of our population and for all intents and purposes, a rock in the sea has a GDP of about $400b.  Beyond basic literacy Singapore’s education system is ranked in the top 20 in the world. It helps of course that there has been an education system in that country since 1823.

Coming full circle to poverty eradication, there are two ways that I know of for an individual to create value, either through education or experience.

UPE has its issues. The idea is sound but the execution may be wanting.

"A previous generation, which did the proverbial 10 mile trek to and from school, have countless stories about how education made a difference. In single families there are siblings who had climbed out of poverty and others who were wallowing in poverty, the difference being one sibling went to school and the other did not.

Interestingly they started their schooling writing in the dust using sharpened pieces of wood (we call them stylus these days), often under trees and many times there was no school when it rained.

They came out fine and many of them lead or have led this country.


 

 

 

 

Tuesday, February 21, 2023

SAPS; UGANDA’S FAVOURITE BOGEY MAN

Picture this, you are in a world of hurt. Your income can not cover a month as the demands on that money –school fees, rent, fuel, food are just overwhelming. As if that is not enough, you lose your job. So, you go to your neighbour who is better off, for a loan.

Your neighbour would love to help, but more importantly he wants to get the money he lends you back, at some pre-determined point in the future. He is not a charity.

So, he sets some conditions for you if he is to lend you the money. Getting a job may not be easy, so most immediately he makes it a condition that you cut back on your lifestyle – move into a cheaper house, shift your kids to less expensive schools, cut out morning and evening tea and on some days you can eat two instead of one meal.

In the meantime, he wants you to look for a job. He may even be willing to pay your school fees to upgrade your qualifications. He wants to improve his chances of being paid back.

You have a choice to put pride aside, bite the bullet and accept the prescription in order to get the loan or tell your neighbour to go to hell and go and beg or con someone else who will lend you the with less onerous conditions.

Extrapolate this to the national level and these are the choices that faced the NRM and the Obote II before them.

"When the NRM came to power in 1986 not only were the national coffers bare, but also the economy had shrunk below its level fifteen years prior. In fact, it took almost 15 years from 1986 to grow the economy back to where it was in 1971...

After trying to get the economy back on its feet on our own resources failed, they turned to the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) for help.

To access financing from these two Bretton Wood institutions they had to sign up to some conditions, which basically were to cut back on government spending and raise tax collections – Structural Adjustment Programs (SAPs).

This is not high finance, its commonsense.

Among the things government had to do was to shrink the size of government, sell loss making parastatals and liberalise the economy, let the private sector drive growth. In terms of raising taxes the Uganda Revenue Authority(URA) was created and invested more in infrastructure.

The measures to cut costs meant for starters, quite a few people lost their jobs a government was downsized and parastatals were sold off. Government struggled or cut budgets to things like university education and sports.

It is understandable why people were not happy with it.

"NRM tried to do it alone, thinking they could print money to climb out of the economic hole they found themselves, but this only made matters worse, with inflation hitting 250 percent a year...

To put that inflation rate in perspective it means prices were doubling every four months. That meant if you paid one million in school fees for your kids in January when you went back for second term it would be two million shillings and in third term would be four million shillings. we were here screaming when the price of petrol went up from sh4000 to sh5000 a 25 percent increment in a year, what would we be saying in 1987 when inflation was galloping out of control?

So when I hear people criticizing SAPs I think two things, either they were the beneficiaries of the economic chaos or they don’t know what they are talking about. I found that more times than not it is the latter rather than the former.

The main criticism of the SAPs was that it opened up our economies to the acquisition of our “assets” by foreign capital.

In Uganda’s case we are being very generous by classifying our parastatals as assets. An asset makes you money but these companies were a drain on the treasury, diverting money for more essential services to prop up under capitalised and badly run companies. People say if only government had recpaitalised the companies they would have been fine. When I hear this I don’t know whether to laugh or cry.

Government was so broke that it shut down Uganda airlines because it could not afford the sh10b (about $10m) a month it cost to keep it afloat. Today government would fill little pain with such payments.

If our “assets” were taken it was because of our own weakness. Kenya across the border from us did not have to let go of their state enterprises, because they were actually net positive contributors to the budget.

Now I hear President William Ruto is looking to flog them on the open market to raise money to clear some of the country’s huge debt. Common sense.

 


Monday, February 6, 2023

UGANDA SUGAR GETTING A BITTER TASTE

When history is written the NRM (National Resistance Movement) will be credited with resuscitating the sugar industry and then killing it.

For the first time in almost 10 years sugar production fell in 2022 on account of falling sugar cane production and a concentration of a sugar mills in the Busoga region, which has triggered unfair and unsustainable competition.

This has led to jump in sugar prices and jeopardising of a recently won sugar market in Kenya.

When the NRM came to power in 1986, years of neglect from the 1970s led to the collapse of the sugar industry – factories fell into disrepair and fields were abandoned.

The NRM helped the three major players Kakira Sugar Works, Sugar corporation of Uganda Ltd (SCOUL) in Lugazi and Kinyara Sugar ltd in Bunyoro, to get back on their feet. Over nearly three decades the three rehabilitated and expanded their plants and use of sugar cane out growers to the point that by 2014 total production had grown to 438,000 tons enough to meet local market demands of about 350,000 tons and a surplus to export to the region, especially Kenya where there own sugar industry had collapsed....

In addition, the industry was directly employing 20,000 workers and many thousands more indirectly up and down the value chain.

The year 2014 is important because it’s from around that time that new sugar mills licensed irregularly by the trade ministry begun production and started a boom-and-bust cycle in the industry that threatens the gains of the existing investors and a future collapse of the industry.

“The trade ministry aided by some local politicians in Busoga  pushed for the licensing of these new mills, without insisting they have their own nucleus fields, which means they started stealing cane from the existing outgrowers who were licensed to Kakira and Lugazi,” an industry player told Business Vision.

The major investment in the sugar industry is not the plant and machinery but the development of the plantation and setting up outgrower schemes. The new players sought to short circuit the process by setting up plants and hoping to poach cane from the existing players.

The business model has been that the millers have a nucleus estate – Kakira has about 23,000 acres and has developed an additional 15,000 acres in Kayunga for a total of 38,000 acres, SCOUL has about 30,000 acres and then develop an outgrower network, which is often multiples of the neucleus estate and supports thousands of farmers.

“Politicians complained that out growers were being paid peanuts for their cane but they did not factor in the inputs the big millers had put in –- ferterliser, pesticides, research, extension services, transport and even some loans to tide the farmers over the periods where they had no cash. All these costs came off the price of cane delivered to the factory,” the industry source.

 Farmers excited by the new dynamic increased sugar cane production – with production jumping from 334,000 tons in 2013 to 438,000 tons. But supply and demand factors came into play and the once lucrative prices they were getting for their cane fell leading to a plummeting of production to 344,000 tons in 2017. With low supplies prices went up again and the industry recovered with production jumping to 622,243 tons in 2021.

With increased production prices went down to sh90,000 at the beginning of 2022 but ended the year at sh220,000 a ton.

This is a result of two factors farmers having decided to ditch the crop when prices collapsed but also because immature cane has been harvested in previous years affecting current production.

"Sugar cane in our part of the world matures at 18 months, when the optimum sugar content is achieved. Harvesting before that time means you will need more cane to produce a unit of sugar, but also jeopardise future harvests....

The instability in the industry has far reaching ramifications for livelihoods in the sugar growing areas, future investments in the sector and may put paid to our future export plans.

As it is now there is more sugar milling capacity in Busoga and Buganda than there is sugar cane to crush, as a result most the millers are operating at less than half of their full capacity. Existing players have no incentive to invest more.

“The assistance farmers is reducing, Why should I support the farmer when I am not guaranteed of his cane on harvest?” the source said.

As a result farm yields have fallen around Busoga from about 120 tons of cane per hectare to half that amount. This means famers now need twice as much land to produce the same amount of sugar, which has far reaching consequences for food security in the area.

“When prices jump farmers forget about food production and commit more of heir land to sugar cane production. So as cane prices fall hunger can be a very real problem in the region.”

To add salt to injury there has been a proliferation of weigh bridges in the area. Weigh bridges have been set up by private individuals who can take possession of sugar cane and pay the farmers cash. Originally farmers used to deliver straight to the factory, where not only quantity but quality was checked.

“Now these illegal weighbridges are just checking for quantity. So immature cane is taken as well,” the source said.

The seduction to the farmer is obvious but even more so for the growing middlemen who operate between the farmer and the mills.

“Now the roads are lined with trucks loaded with cane and the traders phones are beeping all the time with price quotes from this miller or the other. When they get a price they like the send the trucks off to the miller,” a trader told Business Vision.

"As it is now cane prices are high making our sugar uncompetitive in the export market. That may not be a problem as a soon cane prices will crash again. But our export markets cannot wait....

“Kenya government has accorded permission to import 100,000 tons duty free sugar from India/Thailand for home consumption,” a senior industry official complained. “And once the importers get a foothold, we will go back to the Kenyans fighting our exports.”

Our export price was up to $957 per ton dramatically up from $648 earlier in the year.

And the solutions industry players say, are within reach.

For starters government needs to stop the licensing of millers in the Busoga region and all existing factories must develop a nucleus estate of at least 2500 acres; weigh bridges should be shut down and farmers deliver their cane directly to the factory and an advisory committee be set up as stipulated under the Sugar Act 2020, which will have the power to implement decisions within the legal framework immediately. Ian addition government should undertake a study and zone the sugar growing areas to allow for orderly expansion and proper development of the sector.

"The unplanned licensing of new millers by the trade ministry, without insisting they develop their own fields and cane supply chains, is leading invariably to the collapse of the sugar industry in Busoga. Ministry officials were unavailable to comment on the subject.

It has happened before. In the 1970s and 1980s Uganda sugar production supplied the region. The giant millers at Mumias and Chemilil  in western Kenya, both parastatals were brought to their knees through poor management and connivance with importers. The use of pirate millers was instrumental in bringing about that scenario.

“If we continue like this (licensing new millers) we will kill the industry and the suffering to the region is hard to calculate. These new players do not care about the regional or national economy, they just want to make money whether the industry survives or not,” the industry source said.

 

 

Must Read

BOOK REVIEW: MUSEVENI'S UGANDA; A LEGACY FOR THE AGES

The House that Museveni Built: How Yoweri Museveni’s Vision Continues to Shape Uganda By Paul Busharizi  On sale HERE on Amazon (e-book...