Showing posts with label aid. Show all posts
Showing posts with label aid. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 11, 2025

CHICKEN COMING HOME TO ROOST WITH USAID SUSPENSION

US President Donald Trump’s administration has thrown the aid industry into a panic with suspension a week ago of his country’s charity arm, USAID.

It has been reported since, that billions of dollars have been put on ice, thousands around the world will be out of a job and millions of beneficiaries are looking forward to a very uncertain future.

Created in 1961 by the John F. Kennedy administration, USAID has been involved in supporting, among other things global health, food security, democracy and governance initiatives.

The Trump administration accuse them of being fat and lazy and even worse, of being corrupt and money launderers. Allegations have been rehashed of how only a fraction of the aid actually reaches the intended beneficiaries, with the bulk of it going to administration, procurements and high living.

For these and many more accusations, the aid industry has come under heavy criticism for decades. These accusations are not new or unique to USAID.

The industry’s record has been spotty at best and dismal at worst.

"For instance since the 1960s Africa has been a recipient of more aid than the Marshall plan, that reconstructed war torn Europe after the second world war, but remains riven with poverty, disease and war...

Aid campaigners would blame that on poor governance on the continent. On the flip side others would argue that bad governance on the continent is a direct result of over reliance on aid. A situation that did not arise by mistake.

The history of development shows that countries advance by mobilizing their own resources – land, labour and capital, to improve the living standards of their people. This has forced governments to move from autocratic monarchies to more inclusive democracies, as the political elite had to negotiate with the people to pay taxes to finance development.

The monarchs of Europe thought they would have their cake and eat it, taxing their subjects to finance their lifestyle and questionable wars, without being accountable to the people. They did this for a time –for centuries, before the people rose up and said enough is enough. Many monarchs paid with their heads for resisting the new power sharing arrangements with their subjects.

The lesser developed countries of Africa were promised they could short circuit this development process by first colonizing us and then in post-colonial Africa, by providing us with aid.

In hindsight aid has not been about transforming society or development, but about influence peddling. Aid has been the carrot that kept us in line. And as long as we kept in line, it mattered little what our leaders did with the money, hence the eruption of corruption in post-independence Africa and the lack of economic transformation.

Aid has given African governments a free pass not to develop relationships with their people (democracy), by abrogating funding responsibility to the aid industry. That is why for instance we are tearing our hair out because USAID was a central player in the health industry and their departure is an existential threat for many.

It is easier to fly to Washington (per diems all around) and negotiate for more money than it is to negotiate with your population to pay more tax.

The truth is we have been lulled into a false sense of security with all this aid sloshing around.

Shortly after the NRM came to power there was a school feeding program instituted because, coming out of war, harvests were not the best. By 1990 it was determined we did not need that food aid any more. I remember the end to that food aid – mainly chicken curry and tinned fish, almost caused strikes because the school kids had developed a taste for the tinned food and could not imagine living without it.

Today its inconceivable Uganda would need food aid, but one can see how dependency could have been easily created.

The suspension and possible closure of USAID should be cause for soul searching.

"We need to ask ourselves how a foreign entity can be so central to the health of our people? An entity, which on the face of it, may have altruistic motives but is susceptible to the political vagaries of a country for who our welfare is not top of their agenda?

The record will show that aid is insidious in its creation of dependency. Because we have aid we cannot marshall home grown remedies to our lack of revenues to finance our development. Why think hard when someone is falling over themselves to throw money at you.

I am not hopeful, but this event should make us take a long overdue look at how we can mobilise our own resources and how we prioritise the expenditure of those resources.

But as I said I am not very hopeful, especially since USAID or a variation of it, will return within the year.

 

Friday, February 7, 2025

USAID: TIME FOR A HARD RESET

So USAID may be closing office soon. A big blow to our health sector for one. USAID is key in provision of antiretrovirals, anti-malaria fight and everytime we have a haemorragic fever outbreak or the other.

With a health budget of sh3trillion or about sh65,000 per Ugandan, the argument for help with our health budget is not difficult to make.

It would make sense that if USAID was suspended we would have to rearrange the rest of our budget to fill in the gaps that have ensued. We would have to take a long hard look at  our health priorities and arrange expenditure to reflect this.

We would have to ask ourselves some hard questions. Do we need such a big government or not? Can we cut back on our travel budgets with their attendant per diems and readopt virtual meetings? Do we need to stop the lip service and go after the corrupt without fear or favour?

We would want to look again at our taxes. Do we need to raise them? Or at least put more effort into roping more people into the tax net? Collecting less than 20 percent of GDP is nothing to write home about.

"Interestingly this situation we find ourselves in, has a lot to do with the donor largesse we have enjoyed over the last four decades...

The progression of development went roughly as follows. 

When the monarchs of Europe wanted more money to fund their lavish lifestyles and fight more wars, they looked to tax the people more. At some point the people said enough, we need to have more say in the way our taxes are spent. Under pressure the monarchs allowed for the creation of parliaments to, among other things, make sure their monies were being spent for the benefit of the tax payers. Monarchs who resisted, had their and their families´ heads lopped off.

They did not have the benefit of foreign aid, maybe when they went out and colonized countries and appropriated their resources for themselves. But for the most part they had to rely on their own resources to develop.

What this meant was taxing their populations. But you couldn’t just tax your populations any howly. There had to be a negotiation -- If we pay you more we expect more. And if you don’t leave up to our contract we kick you out at the next polls.

And that is how democracy evolved as a continuous dialogue and negotiation between the power elite and the citizen.

Unfortunately for us, this process was short circuited by first colonialism and then by aid.

Now our governments, when their budgets fall short, the knee jerk reaction is to fly abroad to beg for alms. It is much easier than negotiating with your people for more taxes...

As a result not only has the evolution of democracy been stalled but we are also very corrupt. After all it’s not our money we are stealing and as long as the government pays it back, who cares. Imagine though if more people paid taxes, than the less than two million who currently do, there would more noise about corruption.

So by bailing out our governments the aid industry encourages corruption, frustrates the development of institutions and then it is no wonder that after billions of dollars have been thrown at the continent over the last seven decades, we have little to show for it.

But one can see how this state of affairs is unlikely to reverse soon. 

"The US needs the influence that comes with USAID’s activities. The recipient governments need more and more aid to forestall the hard discussions they will inevitably have to have with their populations. A vicious cycle that cannot be broken without much discomfort and pain...

This USAID situation should serve as time for intense soul searching, leading to a hard reset.

 

Tuesday, August 15, 2023

SAYING BYE TO WORLD BANK BILLIONS, FOR NOW

The World Bank last week announced it would not be contracting any new assistance to Uganda, their response to our enacting of the Anti-Homosexuality law earlier this year.

This was not an announcement to thumb your nose at.

"The World Bank has been front and center of jumpstarting Uganda’s economy over the last four decades. Currently they have more than $5b (sh18.5trillion) in projects in areas as diverse urban redevelopment, agriculture, environment protection, energy, education, health and digital development among others....

These current projects reaching back to 2013 are riding on the back of and in support of fundamental economic reforms that saw this country liberalise the economy. The liberalisation of the economy not only unlocked local initiative, but has led to huge foreign direct investment into the economy.

The reform process has been more successful in Uganda than in other places because Kampala has embraced the logic of the reforms.

It was basic economics, to resuscitate the economy we needed to increase production, to increase production we need to improve infrastructure and remove inefficiencies like government parastatals. People who are hankering for a return to parastatals either have forgotten this context or have ulterior motives.

This mutually beneficial partnership has clearly come to a cross roads. The World Bank says the anti-homosexuality law undermines efforts to have inclusive development for everybody regardless of race, gender or sexuality.

Uganda on the other hand enacted the law through parliament, the representatives of the people, a democratic process.

"It would not be a stretch to interpret the World Bank’s action as saying, “if you want our billions, you have to drop the law.” It takes your breath away, when you narrow it down to its bare essentials.

It should serve as a wakeup call to us.

Our wellbeing and that of generations of Ugandans to come is really up to us. Everybody else can only be an enabler or hinderance to our developmental ambitions.

In this journey others will have their own values and priorities with which they will choose to help or not. They have choices, we don’t. Development has to happen with or without the helpers.

That being said our dependence on donor support is long past its sale by date. We have the means to mobilise our own resources.

We have a budget of sh50trillion, which has to be adjusted not to reflect this new reality, as more than half of it is going to be underwritten by the donors. WE all know that we are not collecting as much revenue as we should, the excuse has always been we area largely informal economy.

As an indicator of how much money we are leaving on the table, last year more than sh170trillion flowed through mobile money platforms. This is more than thrice the size of the budget and the size of the entire economy at $47b. As an indicator of economic activity few indicators beat this.

"The problem is not that the economy is largely informal but that we are not exercising creativity and innovation to collect what is due from all citizens...

I have always argued that we need to tax all land in Uganda. Not only will it increase our revenue collections but even better it will increase the productivity of those lands. If I have my acres of idle land and you slap a sh100,000 tax on every acre I will either have to put it to work, that it pays for itself or sale or lease it to someone who can put it to good use.

But also we need to stop thinking of tax according to the text book. I was a supporter of the tax on mobile money transactions and even on data because these are all economic activities or proxies for economic activities that need to be taxed. I know the arguments about financial inclusion and access to the internet, but anything to make these more productive, which tax does, is welcome.

When the colonialists came to Uganda and wanted us to grow coffee they instituted a poll tax, a tax on every grown man, that forced us to sell something – our labour or goods to pay the tax. Coffee was useful and hence our huge small holder coffee farmer population, which feeds into us now being the biggest exporter of coffee on the continent.

"The seduction of aid is that it is easier to access than taxes. To introduce or raise taxes governments have to negotiate with their people, show some quid pro quo. You pay taxes and we will deliver public goods. Governments don’t like such pressure. It is easier to hop on a plane to Washington DC and over cocktails and canapes, sign aid contracts – per diems all around. The lender will not care as much as the local whether the money is employed for its intended use, more than if he gets paid.

This will undoubtedly have a ripple effect through the donor community.

Locally we may very well have to change the way we think about democracy. For example how do we cut public expenditure for example, in the size of our current parliament? Do we think MPS would ever vote to cede their seats in the house? If push comes to shove how do you do it using the current processes in place?

The move by the World Bank is unprecedented since they pulled out of Uganda during the Idi Amin era, this might just be the push we needed to become more self-reliant.

 

Must Read

BOOK REVIEW: MUSEVENI'S UGANDA; A LEGACY FOR THE AGES

The House that Museveni Built: How Yoweri Museveni’s Vision Continues to Shape Uganda By Paul Busharizi  On sale HERE on Amazon (e-book...