Showing posts with label East African Community. Show all posts
Showing posts with label East African Community. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 21, 2022

WALKING THE TALK ON DRIVING EXPORTS

A few weeks ago our officials and businessmen trooped to the Democratic Republic of Congo(DRC) to announce Uganda to the newest member of the East African Community (EAC), in a series of meeting held in Goma, eastern DRC and in the capital, Kinshasa.

We would be amiss if we did not look covetously at our only western neighbour’s vast bounty of natural resources, 90 million population and $60b economy and want to position for the opportunity.

"The way we have seen opportunities go begging in Southern Sudan and even Somalia, where we have contributed in their stabilization with blood, sweat and tears, can very well be replicated in DRC. It is not automatic that because we are their neighbours and that we have historical trade links we will be the biggest beneficiaries of the entry of DRC into the EAC.

Previously government has been content to let our businessmen sink or swim in foreign lands. If there are businessmen who have made an impression abroad it has been largely due to their won effort. Hopefully with last week’s meeting in DRC government is beginning to understand what its role has to be in supporting its businessmen to make inroads in foreign markets.

This is an important discussion. With a population of under 50 million, we do not have a big enough market to support a credible industrial base that can employ our people and raise living standards all around. We need to reach beyond our markets to support our planned industries.

The EAC is a good start. But government needs to be more deliberate in helping our businessmen penetrate even our neighbour’s markets. To feed those markets our businessmen will have to expand their production capacities, which will create more jobs not only in the factories but along the whole value chain.

We need not reinvent the wheel. The South East Asians did it in the second half of the last century and are now the world’s biggest exporters, all this on a natural endowment base that does not hold a candle to our own natural endowments.

It did not happen by mistake. At the time their planners determined that they must export to survive they were plagued with the same issues are we are now poor, unskilled, fast growing populations that were a ticking political time bomb if not put to good use.

They too started by aggregating their markets, using that as a launch pad for their products into the world.

"But the more successful countries went a step further. In negotiating market access, providing transport and communication infrastructure, concessional funding to business targeting foreign market among other things....

Bringing those learning here, how would we help our businessmen penetrate the DRC market?

As part of a national strategy to promote exports first to our neighbours and then beyond, we need to look at our current capacities and target markets where our products – food, cooking oil, cement, soft drinks, beer and plastics, can find virgin markets, in our case South Sudan and Eastern DRC and facilitate trade at a policy level, which policies will inform the nature of interventions to make in the targeted markets.

 

"Government’s plan to partner with DRC in building more than 200km of road network in the east of giant central African neighbour is a good start. But it is only a start...

Eastern Congo alone is more than twice the size of Uganda. In Uganda we have about 6000 km of paved road and we are not doing well. That’s just to show how 223 km in eastern DRC is a molecule in the ocean.

They have an extensive network of airfields however, so the two governments may consider how to upgrade these for interregional travel.

What businessmen have said is key too is some sort of export guarantee scheme. The way it works is based on the reality that to promote international trade, credit has to be allowed, an export guarantee scheme would allow our exporters some relief incase their deal goes south.

The trouble our traders have suffered in South Sudan should be a lesson. This is important because once credit is allowed a lot more business can be done and our businessmen can quickly expand their market share.

In addition, we need to facilitate the collaboration with financial institutions. Carrying wads of cash around only puts our businessmen at risk and increases the chances of fraud. What is taken for granted now in travelling to better countries is that you can deposit your money in Kampala and still go and transact in Europe or Asia. We should move quickly to make this possible in eastern Congo.  Maybe we can facilitate the mobile companies to do this for starters.

Many years ago I remember enjoying a Nile Special beer in Bunia, Eastern Congo. It was a sight for sore eyes. The only problem was there wasn’t much to go around before the bar run out and the entire had run out. New supply was not expecting more stock for a week.

There probably hundreds of opportunities going begging like that today.


Monday, May 30, 2022

TO SAVE THE ENVIRONMENT EACOP MUST GO ON

I had a déjà vu moment last week seeing some breathless young lady accost French President Emmanuel Macron entreating him to stop the development of the East African Crude Oil Pipeline (EACOP).

The EACOP is the 1400 km pipeline that will evacuate Ugandan oil from western Uganda to the Tanzanian port city of Tanga.

The earnest young lady explained that the pipeline (As if Macron does not know) that the pipeline would encourage the use of fossil fuels which are major driver behind climate change, whose effects are manifest in droughts, floods and even the increased frequency of sand storms the middle east is suffering currently.

It took me back nearly 20 years when all sorts of activists jumped out of the woodwork to protest the development of the 250 MW Bujagali dam. Led by the local agents of an NGO called the International Rivers Network.

The anti-Bujagali lobby argued at the time that damming the river would displace hundreds and destroy the scenic beauty of the area.

"So that time they could not hide behind climate change, especially since hydroelectricpower is one of the most ecofriendly energy sources, they argued for scenic beauty...

One local activist was quoted as saying at the time, "The real issue in Uganda is not electricity but poverty. Currently the majority of Ugandans have no money for electricity, for they are below the poverty line. Production of more electricity will not reduce use of fuelwood and charcoal until deliberate programs are evolved to reduce poverty and the cost of power."

Since Bujagali came on line in 2012 – the world has not collapsed around our ears, but in fact, more than a million households have been hooked up to the grid. Those are a thousand families who left to find their own devices without electricity, would have used kerosene lamps or diesel generators for their lighting at night or used more charcoal in their kitchens and would have been less productive.

Access to power is just below 50 percent today but this is a far cry to the just over five percent of the population who had access to power before Bujagali came online.

It would be interesting to see how much more economic activity has resulted from this development and further still how many people were lifted out of poverty or at least saw their incomes increase as a consequence.

I want to bet that the Bujagali activists now live in houses – they probably built with their paychecks from the campaign, powered by the dam fought so vehemently.

"The anti-Bujagali activists were dead wrong then as the anti-EACOP campaigners are today....

In fact, to stop these developments will be to damage further the very environment they claim to be seeking to protect.

Because it is true that in our part of the world the biggest cause of environmental degradation, is not the fat cats who are reclaiming wetlands for construction, but the poor who have decimated 90 percent of our forest cover in search of new farmland and firewood for their survival.

The history of poverty eradication is quite clear. Countries interested in doing so, exploit their natural endowments to create economic activity, which leads to a rise in incomes across the board and therefore reduction in poverty. In some countries they have done it so well they have surplus resources to bankroll a welfare state, where everyone is entitled to an income in or out of a job. This did not happen by wishful thinking.

"Because we do not have the luxury of enslaving people or colonizing other countries to push economic growth, we have to employ what we have, that is our natural resources and our people. Our confusion about how to do this – due partly to the handsome paychecks from foreign environmental lobbyists, means we are not even doing a good job on this front.

That being said the exploitation of these resources can be done in a way that does not cause irreparable damage to our environment. As it stands now voluminous environmental impact assessments have been carried on the project and provisions have been put in place to mitigate against the damage to the environment to the extent possible. This is not the Niger delta.

If we are truly sincere about conserving the environment we should be poring over these reports to ensure every possible measure was taken to conserve the environment.

The increased revenues to government and to the private citizens involved in the industry, have the potential to improve the provision of public goods and social services that will give more and more people a chance to climb out of poverty.

You do not fight poverty by dishing out money at street corners but by empowering people through better education and health to take advantage of and to create new economic activity.

So if to banish poverty takes the exploitation of our natural endowments and some do-gooder, clearly who knows better than us what is best for us, is fighting this time tested progression, you have to wonder what their intentions are.

"To be charitable to them I would say they are ignorant parotters of slogans on an issue they have no clue about (African poverty), he more cynical view would be that, it is in their interest to remain in our state of under development so our living standards do not rise to their level, because they would have to better share the globe’s resources...

The latter is the conspiracy theory I choose to favour.

 


Monday, April 25, 2022

ACRES OF DIAMONDS IN THE EAC

The story is told of the man who frustrated with eking a living on his farm, sold it and took off into the world to find his fortune.

After trying this and that with little success and his finances dwindling to a drip, he decided to go back, with the hope that his own may treat him better. When he got back he was shocked to find where his farm once was a thriving diamond mining enterprise.

The moral of the story is that we often miss the opportunity staring us in the face for speculative fortune further afield.

Last week the Private Sector Foundation of Uganda hosted a dialogue on “The status of East Africa community process on investments and job creation”

The event, co-sponsored by the Mastercard Foundation, came with equal part jaw dropping surprise and headshaking despair.

"New entrant Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) comes with a bounty of gifts, which include the fact that a third of all the world’s copper and cobalt reserves are underground there. We more or less knew that. But when we heard that assuming Uganda exploits its oil optimally we could have an economy by 2050 equal to the current size of the South African economy -- $500b, you had to seat up and pay attention....

The reincarnated East African Community (EAC) has been in existence for the last two decades, while the free movement of goods and services came with the common market protocol in 2010. In this time we have seen trade within the region grow to about 20 percent from a six percent at the turn of the century.

As an example it is reported that at least 80 million youth are unemployed in the region. Unemployed as used in this context means a person who has done paid work in the last week. So the reality is definitely much worse. The Economic Policy Research Center (EPRC) estimates we need to create 120 million jobs to plug the hole.

With a new regional population of about 300m and a combined GDP of just under $300b and the freeing up of the movement of goods and people, job creation should come easier to the region.

The free movement of goods and people will boost industry and services with a corresponding increase in jobs.

However, we learnt that Non-tariff barriers are holding back our full potential. While goods move around largely tax free in the region, powerful interest groups have conspired with their respective states to throw up other barriers to trade, to protect their own interests be they their own inefficient industries or importation deals from outside the community.

So suddenly your maize or eggs don’t meet their health standards, never mind the market for our eggs have been growing in the last few years. Or your milk, it is suspected to cheap to be locally produced, you must have sailed it in all the way from Australia and smuggled it in via the DRC or how is it that now a truck can only make two round trips a month to the coast now when in 1977 it could do two round trips in a week on roads that were in worse shape than they are now.

It would be easy to dismiss these as teething pains of the young community, but we need to nip them in the bud before they become entrenched in our way of doing things.

Besides that, some people have made the argument that quality of the population is lacking, be it in terms of purchasing power or capacity to actualize our potential. But its probably a chicken and egg situation, do you open up to trade and raise incomes and therefore the quality of your people or do you wait to improve the people’s quality and then the trade and increased economic activity follows? I think it is the former rather than the latter.

That being said the respective government really need to be more proactive in improving the quality of the people by rejigging the education system, improving health care and other services.

Making entrepreurship part of the curriculum on day one and business support services to existing businesses, may make the difference between Ugandans benefitting maximally from the new opportunities or we may be in danger of providing only office messengers to the region.

On an intellectual level we know our acres of diamonds are under our feet, but the will to do what is necessary to unearth those diamonds seems is slow in materializing.

 


Monday, April 4, 2022

DRC ENTRANCE INTO EAC A GAMECHANGER

The Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC) was ad mitted to the East African Community (EAC) earlier this week in an event that probably did not garner as much attention as it should.

In 1997 after Laurent Kabila backed by Uganda and Rwanda overthrew Mobutu Seseseko word was that some investment bankers had come together to mobilise resources for the infrastructural development of our western neighbour.

The plan easily was going to cost billions of dollars and was intended to not only join every corner of the country to the Atlantic coast but to its neighbours as well, it was believed to be what the giant African nation to unlock its full potential.

Believe it or not the Congo’s road network for instance so bad that a trip that would ordinarily take a day on all-weather roads can take up to a week when the rain pours and turns it into a muddy morass. Rail transport is non-existent, water transport on the River Congo is dominated by rudimentary vessels and telecommunication services are not universal.

The aforementioned plan however, came apart when the Uganda and Rwanda fell out with Kabila and civil war resumed. To my knowledge the plan has not been resuscitated in the form I heard about then.

Interestingly they were not the first to habour such dreams. In the 1960s and American financier Edward Detwiler drew up a 50-year development plan that would involve the development of infrastructure and exploitation of the country’s mineral wealth. He had got audience with the then Prime Minister Patrice Lumumba who was looking favourably on the plan, before he was overthrown and murdered. The bill for the project at the time was $1.9b...

The attraction is clear. It has been estimated that the DRC’s mineral wealth is valued at $12trillion, at the time I heard this the US economy was $11trillion. To get an indication of the untapped potential of the DRC the current GDP of the country is $46b. What a scandal.

We have heard the numbers. With the entrance of the DRC the region’s GDP rise almost 20 percent to $267b and an additional 90 million people will join the market bringing it to about 300 million people. While most of DRC’s population is poor, it has huge urban populations that can be serviced by the region. Kinshasa alone has a population of 15 million more than thrice the population of Nairobi, which is the next largest city in the EAC.

Ever since the resuscitation of the EAC in 2000 trade between member states has grown to about 20 percent compared to six percent two decades ago. This freer movement of goods in the region has cushioned us from the global financial crisis of 2008 and even more so during the Covid pandemic.

That it is still very low compared to South Africa Development Community (SADC) where half of their trade is done within the community or Asia where the number is 70 percent or the EU which is even higher.

Intra-EAC trade is hampered by poor infrastructure and non-tariff barriers.

With the DRC the poor transport networks are a major hindrance.

Uganda in collaboration with DRC is in the process of developing 223km of road in eastern Congo, which it is estimated will more than double trade flows between the two countries.

Since people have forgotten the Ugandan experience, laying down roads in DRC – initially all weather and then tarmac, will have a transformative effect on the population of the country and the region. Congolese will have access to markets, raising their incomes and becoming a more formidable market for the region.

If you think about it the inadequacy of the transport infrastructure through the DRC is hampering communication between north Africa and South Africa, East and West Africa. A road and rail network will therefore be a game changer for the continent as a whole...

It would make more sense now for those investment bankers to dust off their business plans and raise money for the DRC’s infrastructure.

And by the way we have not even begun talking about exploiting that the country’s vast mineral potential yet.

 


Monday, December 13, 2021

BOMBS ON ADF AND THE LARGER QUESTION OF REGIONAL INTEGRATION

Two weeks ago our own Uganda People’s Defence Forces (UPDF) attacked Allied Democratic Forces (ADF) bases in eastern Congo.

Reports had it that the artillery and airstrikes were concentrated on an area of about 150 square kilometers. The ADF cannot have enjoyed the experience and while news is scanty, given the area that was flattened fatalities must have run in dozens never mind casualties.

Unfortunately, the operation is open ended with no time frame set to pacify an area, mostly dense tropical forest, bigger than the whole of Uganda.

The repercussions on our budget will be negative but we have to trust that this is a sacrifice we have to make with the long term in mind.

"For starters the security threat that the ADF pose cannot be overemphasized, but even more important is the security threat of having huge lawless, ungovernable areas bordering us. If it is not the ADF it will be someone else who has evil intentions on us using the Congolese jungles as his launch pad...

It does not help that there are more than 1 hundred armed militia’s roaming the area praying on the population and one would imagine happy to sell their “expertise” to the highest bidder. The emergence of these militias is not all down to criminal intent. In an area where the state has been absent for coming to half a century people have to protect themselves and sometimes in so doing they may just decide to prey on weaker neighbours and soon there is a full scale arms race in the area. And what is to stop them one day cross our imaginary borders and attacking on Ugandans?

The sustainable thing to do is to bring the area under some kind of central control by force initially, which should have been the job of Kinshasa but more importantly by creating an environment in which economic activity can flourish.

Sustainable peace comes from interdependence. Trade is right up there as one of the best ways to create interdependence. When we have no mutual benefit to ourselves war and predation become a real possibility.

So the collaboration with the Kinshasa to improve the road network in eastern Congo is actually what we should be focused on. Any military victories will be temporary but making movement in the area easier is not only useful from a security perspective but will automatically encourage the movement of people, goods and services.

An interesting story from the Mobutu Ssese Seko era explains why DRC – larger than western Europe, has less tarmaced roads than Uganda. During a state visit to neighbouring Central African Republic, then president Jean Bedel Bokassa drove Mobutu through wide, tree lined streets to his palace. At some point Mobutu, who was supposed to be impressed by this show of development, couldn’t hold it any longer, “My friend these goods roads of yours are how you will be overthrown!” he said.

This egocentric thinking has doomed the DRC to confusion and poverty.

"As it is now DRC and mostly the eastern expanse is fast becoming Uganda’s largest trading partner accounting for up to $400 million in exports. We have seen in our own lifetimes how little tarmac can totally change the economy of neighbourhoods and regions....

The 200 km of paved road that we shall help build in the region are just a tip of what is necessary to unlock the vast potential of that region and may very well serve as a useful stimulus for our economy to rebound in coming years.

If in these times when roads are not usable year around we are doing almost half a billion dollars in trade it is conceivable that we can more than double that with the most basic of road infrastructure in place.

Improved economic activity in the area will make joining up in militias less attractive and once the communities have tasted peace and stability will be loath to support any militias.

"Of course for the DRC they have to step up. Uganda’s presence is at best temporary, we would rather have our sons and daughters back home than roaming the jungles of Congo with a target on their backs....

Which brings us to the wider question of regional integration. It starts with recognizing that our borders, really only lines on paper, do not insulate us from the poverty and underdevelopment on the other side. That shared prosperity of first border communities and then whole regions is how will keep our worst excesses from consuming us all.

If it takes a handful of disheveled types running around playing war, to quicken the cause for integration so be it.

 

 

Monday, August 2, 2021

ECONOMIC EMIGRANTS ARE A SAD INDICTMENT ON UGANDA

This week weight lifter Julius Ssekitoleko was released by police on bond. Last week he was deported from Japan where he had tried to stay on as an illegal immigrant. Sskeitoleko who has struggled to find employment because of the shut down of Kampala’s night life – he is a bouncer, listed this and the fact that his partner is pregnant, as reason for his ill fated move.

It is difficult not to sympathise and most people do.

Recently it was reported that hundreds of young people are being shipped out monthly to the middle east, to find work as menial workers. Again apart from the allure of earning in dollars, these often unskilled workers are struggling to make ends meet here.

It is safe to say that anybody whol leaves this country to work abroad, even the well paid ones, would rather be working at home, close to their friends and family.

Working abroad is not all its cracked out to be, they soon discover that with the high cost of living their incomes are not as juicy as they first seemed.

"While these émigré workers – illegal or otherwise, are sending more than a billion dollars back home annually, that is a fraction of their usefullness to this economy if they were gainfully employed here than abroad....

We are a wasteful country on many levels and that is the reason we can not keep our children at home. Each one of these young people beyond being Ugandans are units of economic output that we are donating to other countries.

Of course, the worst thing we can do is prevent them from living to better themselves, that is so 20th century.

We should start by committing to ensure every Ugandan can find gainful employment in Uganda. That’s where it starts, clearly we have not made that commitment yet.

At the basic level we need to create an environment for business to thrive, so that jobs can be created. There is a lot of work to be done in building infrastructure, producing skilled workers and to ensure property rights are secured. But even more important, if government wants to be really useful, it has to work at creating market access for our goods, locally and abroad...

Creating demand locally is a chicken and egg situation. To create local demand there has to be an increase in incomes across the board, but that only comes when people are gainfully employed. A crude, but unsustainable way to do it, is for government to give relief funds to the most vulnerable in the society. Another crude method that has been used with some success elsewhere is for government to take up local products especially from agriculture.

In the early 1980s Kenya launched a school milk program. Under the program all primary school children would receive 250 mls of milk at least twice a week. With this single stroke Kenyan milk production jumped and Kenya Cooperative Creameries (KCC) became a huge player, graduating to exporting UHT and powdered milk. The initiative was brilliant because aside for the nutritional benefits to the kids it created a huge market for processed dairy products that persists to this day.

Without doubt such or similar initiatives would need a massive outlay of resources from the treasury, but the long term benefit in terms of healthier kids, the building of the productive capacity for us to launch into the export market and the thousands of jobs that would be  created up and down the value chain, would far outweigh the cost.

But the real jump in job creation would  be for government to facilitate access to foreign markets. It was heartening to see new agriculture minister Frank Tumwebaze pushing for Kenya to open its market to our products. Interestingly this was happening as Kenya’s President Uhuru Kenyatta was in the UK suing for greater access to that market for his country’s horticultural produce.

To give a sense of how this can be transformative, a friend went down to South Africa to try and get his coffee on the shelfs of a major supermarket chain. After hearing him out they suggested he start by trying to supply their 14 branches in the Cape Town region. But he soon gave up when faced with the demands. The supermarket chain wanted them to supply 45 tons of their branded coffee every two weeks, but in addition have a constant 45 tons in their warehouses on standby. As if that was not enough payment would be due within 60 days of delivery. He worked out that to meet the demand, he would have to scale up his operations almost four fold – including workers, and that was only for the Cape Town market, forgetting his current clientele. 

Access to markets also means helping our own businessmen to scale up to meet the new demand in quantity and quality. But this can also go to include services especially ICT, financial, education and health services, where we can develop a real competitive advantage if we committed to it and did so systematically.

 There are probably hundreds of ways this can happen. We will not be reinventing the wheel.

But probably more importantly, committing to having everyone be gainfully employed at home will avert scenes like we saw in South Africa two weeks or so ago. There people took advantage of protests against the arrest of former President Jacob Zuma to loot businesses. Over the last two decades  or so South Africa has done a dismal of spreading the wealth around more equitably, instead the powerful and connected have forgotten their commitment to the majority blacks, engaged in corruption on an industrial scale increasing the hopelessness of the everyday man.

If South Africa with the security industrial complex it has can fail to keep the calm, what of us?



Tuesday, June 15, 2021

TO BELIEVE OR NOT BELIEVE THE BUDGET

In last week’s budget we heard that the economy grew by 3.3 percent in this financial year compared to last year when the economy grew by 3.0 percent.

This is pitiful given that, prior to the covid-19 pandemic it was projected that this year the economy would grow by more than 6.0 percent.

During the Absa Bank Uganda post budget forum held on Friday it was interesting to hear various experts note that while the economy had been badly hit it was still showing growth, which has a lot to do with the way our economy is structured.

"It helps of course that we can feed ourselves as a nation. Despite the restrictions on movement and congregation the agriculture sector kept us afloat in this important aspect...

But beyond feeding us our farms also produce our biggest tradables among ourselves and in the region.

Commissioner General John Musinguzi who was a panelist at the Absa Bank forum, which was themed “Implications of the budget proposals on trade and manufacturing” said the two sectors accounted for just over half of the revenue collections.

While both sectors took a hit in the last year they still dominate the revenue collections, which suggests that it was wise for government not to restict the movement of cargo, never mind that truck drivers caused us a lot of grief in hte first pandemic wave.

While Absa mananging director Mumba Kalifungwa along with others were glad to hear governmnet maintained its commitment on the infrastructure development, Damalie Ssali, coutry director at Trademark East Africa however, pointed out that we also need to improve the roads within the country.

She reported that

Uganda loses $1.5m (Sh5.2b) daily from cars idling in Kampala traffic...

They are all connected – agriculture, higher trade volumes and manufacturing revenues and the traffic jams of Kampala.

The losses due to traffic are not just numbers, somebody has to pay for them. Beyond the increase in hypertension among drivers,  its the poorest who bear the burden of these losses in terms of poor service delivery. Because that is money that is disposable income that would have gone into buying goods and services, increasing demand for our products, keeping people in jobs or creating more altogether.

I suspect even the $1.5m daily loss is understated.

The finance ministry’s director of budget Ken Mugambe in speaking about the parish development model said at least sh5trillion has been earmarked for the programs, flowing down to the 10,000-plus parishes. While there are seven pillars of the model, government will focus on three – financial inclusion, beefing up the parish administration structures and data collection.

On one hand people see this as an attempt o byass the middlemen and get resources nearer the household, the critics however, point to the inadequate administration structures as the loophole, which will not only frustrate the program’s inception but also provide an avenue to enrich a few bureaucrats who take advantage of the confusion.

Other critics wonder whether the same work can not be executed through existing government structures and that the parish development model may be a duplication of functions.

"The intention is good, it may be failed by the implementation...

In the parish development model among other things they have provided for extension services, irrigation and bulking of products, which are useful if we are to bring agroindustrialisation into reality.

The truth is

while we can feed ourselves as a country, we do not produce enough surpluses to sustain a robust agro-industrial complex....
Production in the agricultural sector has to make quantum leaps before agorindustrialisation and its benefits of improved farmgate prices, higher export receipts and job creation can be a reality.

Increased agricultural production can increase jobs by more than the million jobs government looks to create by building industrial parks and free trade zones.

Increased production requires a market to absorb it. The East African Community now account for about a quarter of all our trade and the promise of the Africa Continental Free Trade Area look set to snap our increased production. But Uganda Manafacturer’s Association (UMA)  executive director Daniel Birungi, worried that if we do not have robust trade dispute resolution mechanisms as we have seen wth our dealings with Rwanda, where our common border has b een closed for two years, what hope is there for trading efficiently with countries far afield on the continent?

"So while we are feeling the pain of the covid pandemic in our pockets, continued macro economic stability, the improved business environment due to infrastructural improvements and the promise of increased agricultural productivity give us hope for the future....

Time will tell.










Tuesday, March 23, 2021

WHAT CAN WE SAY ABOUT JOHN POMBE MAGUFULI

Former President John Pombe Magufuli breathed his last on Wednesday evening.

His death was an exclamation mark on the last few days, when he had been uncharacteristically out of the public eye. Speculation had been rife that he had contracted Covid-19 and, depending on who you listened to, he was already comatose, shuttling frenetically between Tanzania, Kenya and India to save his life or dead altogether.

The official version is that he died of cardiac arrest.

"In death as in life the man known as the bulldozer –  lovingly or with dread, sharply divided opinion....

Little known is that after his A-level he trained as a science teacher, before he upgraded to a degree and eventually earning in doctorate in chemistry in 2009.

He jumped into politics in 1995 and before he ascended to the presidency he served as transport and works minister, where he earned the moniker “The bulldozer”. His emphasis on infrastructure development as president was obviously influenced by his work in the ministry. Magufuli is credited with pushing projects such as the development of the Standard Gauge Railway, expansion of the Dar es Salaam port, the liquefied natural gas plant among others. His place in Uganda’s history is cemented if only because he was keen that the Hoima-Tanga oil pipeline get off the ground quickly. He openly expressed impatience with Ugandan bureaucracy, whose lackadaisical attitude he could not wrap his mind around, as he had almost absolute power to implement projects in his own country.

His urgency to develop Tanzania’s infrastructure however, contradicted his perceived skepticism about the East African Community, which while he signed up to all the protocols, his government actively discouraged exports from Kenya and Uganda and made working in Tanzania hostile for workers from the region, despite efforts to free the movement of labour around the EAC.

The last part was an understandable reaction from a country, which many years ago under Julius Nyerere took the step to have all their education carried out in Kiswahili. This has hobbled their workforce, making them uncompetitive against their English speaking counterparts in the region. This policy, while it ringfenced jobs for Tanzanian citizens, is unproductive in the long run as it will affect investment into the giant east African nation. The saving grace for Tanzania, maybe that it is so well endowed with natural resources they can write their own check—for now.

Magufuli was voted President of Tanzania in 2015 and quickly captured the public imagination with his campaign against runaway public spending and official corruption. He was not averse to making spot inspections of schools, hospitals and other public institutions, asking hard questions and firing officials on the spot when they waffled and whittled under his withering gaze. The public loved it. He was just the man to fire up Tanzania’s famously sleepy bureaucracy.

Through sheer force of character Magufuli got the public servants, some would say, to accomplish more in terms of public works, in his first term as president than was achieved under previous administrations.

Obviously he stepped on many toes along the way, especially entrenched interest groups that had enjoyed and profited from the status quo.

But the emperor had feet of clay.

Magufuli’s doggedness in trying to lift Tanzania up from the boot straps required an unwavering conviction in his own beliefs and that seemed to work for other things.

Last year the covid-19 pandemic broke out, sweeping from Asia into Europe and the Americas leaving a trail of illness and death in its wake.

As countries scrambled to contain the spread by instituting restrictions on travel and congregation, Magufuli emerged as one of the biggest denialists of the pandemic. He spurned the standard operating procedures promoted to slow the disease spread – washing hands, wearing masks, social distancing and rejected calls to lockdown his country. Tanzania stopped reporting the number of victims and deaths due to Covid-19 in April last year. He went further and declared that Tanzania was Covid-free when neighbouring countries were beginning to report an uptick of cases.  

It will remain a mystery how a scientist, albeit former seminarian, could ignore all the evidence about Covid-19 and choose a contrary path, but whose negative after effects will resound through Tanzania’s history.

Since the beginning of this year some high profile people have died of Covid, like Seif Sharif Hamad, Zanzibar’s first vice-president and it was becoming harder to sweep the situation under the carpet.

As one of his last public pronouncements at the end of February Magufuli conceded that there may be a problem and urged Tanzanians to wear masks, for him it may have been too little too late.


Monday, December 14, 2020

THE EAST AFRICAN COMMUNITY MUST WORK FOR UGANDA

In December 1987 there was shoot out in Busia, on the Uganda-Kenya border. Kenya claimed that Ugandan troops entered their country and were stopped in their tracks. Uganda at the time complained of rebels attacking Ugandan villages from the Kenya said. Presumably our soldiers were in hot pursuit.

There was exchange of fire for a few days until President Yoweri Museveni and his Kenyan counterpart Daniel Arap Moi broke bread in primary school compound in Malaba, the other major border town north of Busia.

At the time there was some mickey mouse outfit – The Force Obote Back Again (FOBA), which was more bluster than substance allegedly operaing in eastern Uganda and working out of western Kenya.

The hostilities were snuffed out within the week.

The Kenyans closed the borders and we had a fuel shortage, which did not do any good for our inflation which that year was running high at 215 percent. 

There was a parallel narrative behind the shooting. 

"That Kenya having considered Uganda a captive market, for almost two decades by that time, was not amused at Uganda’s noises about economic self sufficiency....

The industrial base in western Kenya was predicated on Uganda continuing to be a basket case for a long time.

So the shoot out and subsequent border closing was a shot across Uganda’s bow. A warning that our eastern neighbour can do major damage to our economy if they want. That we should just lie down and continue to be Kenya’s market for finished goods.

Fast foward to today and it seems Kenya is up to its old tricks.

Ugandan exports to its eastern neighbour has been growing in leaps and bounds. So much so that in 2017 we reversed our trade balance – we started exporting more in value than we import from Kenya.

Whereas that is mostly the export of raw materials from Uganda, our manufactures are beginning to  climb as well.

In fact, one of the major drivers of our increased exports to Kenya in 2017, was a jump in processed milk.

In 2019 Uganda’s exports of milk to Kenya came in at $150m bettered as an export earner by only gold and coffee.

Uganda Manufacturers Association (UMA) complained a week ago that Kenya was throwing up non-tarrif barriers against Uganda exports that went against the spirit of the East African common market protocals.

Kenyan technocrats and enforcement agencies, were questioning the origins of Ugandan products, claimed our exports were counterfeit, had institutionalized  harassment of our exporters, raided Ugandan warehouses and were issuing quotas on how much Uganda could export to them. 

"These were all the more painful because Kenyan products were being allowed free access to Ugandan markets....

The EAC common market is a godsend for businesses in the region. It expands markets, can lead to greater job creation and eventual economic transformation.

It also should sharpen competitive advantages. With Uganda beginning to live up to its potential as the regional food basket, it will become increasing obvious that food production should be left to us.

"Trade wars are often triggered by one country trying to protect powerful lobbies at home...
. The offending country will try to couch their actions  in populist rhetoric, claiming to be protecting jobs but in truth it is to protect the interests of a well connected elite.

On the surface of it Uganda’s bargaining position seems weak – we are a landlocked country, who need the markets to expand production at home.

But on the other hand even if our trade balances with Kenya has shifted we are still a major market for their goods. 

Government should consider some retaliatory action against Kenyan goods, which will at least make the EAC secreteriat in Arusha seat up and take notice.

"While an eye for an eye will eventually mean everybody goes blind, its hard to see what choice Uganda has at this point....


Thursday, December 10, 2020

IS IT TIME FOR UGANDA TO REMOVE THE KID GLOVES?


Last week the Uganda Manufacturers’ Association (UMA) complained that unfair trade practices by our East African Community (EAC) were proving detrimental to our local businesses and that government should muster a more robust response than it has currently managed.

According to UMA, Uganda which has served as a market for Kenyan industry for decades is finally coming into its own, seeking to not only manufacture things we previously imported but also to export the products of our factories.

However, they complain that while EAC common market guarantees the unfettered free movement of goods and services between member states our neighbours are not playing ball.

Kenya for instance continues to throw up non-tarif barriers – questioning the origins of our goods, they claim they are counterfeit, smuggled, there is institutionalized  harassment of Ugandan trade, road blocks and raids on Ugandan warehouses and issuance of quotas, all of which are against the spirit of the common market.

UMA complains too that frequent tariff tampering by Tanzania and the border closure by Rwanda has shrunk their share of regional trade.

"These are important complaints that need to be taken seriously in the context of our drive to transform the economy and eliminate poverty...

At the heart of the idea behind the common market was that it would boost our individual industries, create jobs and spur economic transformation. When some countries thin they would rather be protectionist rather than open the cause will be lost.

That being sad this kind of shenanigans are not unique to us. Building common markets is a labour of love that takes ages to create anywhere  in the world.

However, there is a genuine need to speed things along.

It seems Uganda is getting the short end of this stick. While diplomatic protests have been made to the offending parties they seem to ignore them.

President Yoweri Museveni, for who this has been his pet project for decades, should jump into the fray and try and get his counterparts to orgainise their technocrats and enforcers.

"And if we cannot rely on the goodness of the hearts of our neighbours, though not desirable, restricting their access to our markets must be considered until we get an amicable settlement. 


Monday, May 11, 2020

UGANDA DAIRY FARMERS CAUGHT IN KENYA, UGANDA CROSSFIRE

Since the end of last year dairy farmers in western Uganda have lost a major market of their produce as Kenyan authorities have locked out Ugandan milk.
The closure of the Pearl Dairy plant in Biharwe, along the Masaka-Mbarara road, in February has seen demand for milk collapse in Masindi in the west, Kabale in the south west and Isingiro in the south.

"In our area alone at least 1000 liters go to waste daily which has a downward effect on the pricec of milk in the Mbarara and Kiruhura areas, the price has fallen to sh200 from sh800 per liter last year," David Mwine the chairman of the Rukaka Savings & Credit Cooperative Society and a  dairy farmer in his own right.


"The whoe of this region is experiencing losses because farners can not meet their operational costs and are demoralised by the prices of milk. We dont have someone to buy the milk and we are giving it away free."

This is sad state of affairs for the region and the country.
Pearl Dairy's business model is to export up to 90 percent of its production, mostly to Kenya and sell the remainder locally. Its other markets are Rwanda, before the border closure a year ago and the Democratic Republic of Congo.

This has come about because in Uganda, due to lax regulation only about a quarter of all milk produced is processed. In Kenya not only is milk consumptrion more than triple that in Uganda -- 140 liters versus 40 liters per person annually, there is a higher demand for processed milk, more than two thirds of the market is processed milk.


Overt the last three years Pearl Dairy has made significant in roads into the Kenyan market and as of last year, accounted for about a quarter of the milk market in Kenya.

Trouble begun at the end of last year when Kenyan authorities impounded Pearl Dairy's milk claiming it was counterfeit and turned back several of their consignments.

The Uganda government complained to their Kenyan counterparts and a 19-person Kenya team visited the country to ascertain that Uganda producecs all it exports, but the impasse has not been broken.

Hence the Biharwe factory's closure in February.
The ripple effect in the communities that supply the Pearl Dairy has been devastating.

Over the last two years of Pearl Dairy's operaion in the area, through their own extension services, some farmers increase more their yields to 11 liters a day per cow frrom the previous five liters. All this through better managment of their existing herds.

"We have been able to learn best dairy practices. I used to be pastoral farmer, grazing my cows over large areas, i no longer do that and my farm is now a commercial enterprise, my income frrom milk has gone up a lot," Raymond Kaweesi, a pioneer beneficiary of this initiative said.

He has been able to share the learnings and many farmers in his area have seen their fortunes improve as a result.
Pearl Dairy extension services reach more than 600 farms.

"This ecosystem of farmers, traders and transporters built to support the 800,000 liter a day plant, is in danger of being broken up....


"Some farmers have already slaughtered their herds and sold them for beef. Imagine what it will take to get the back into production? Not only in terms of money but also lost trust," a regional leader wondered on condition of anonymity.

It is not clear what the  problem is in Kenya.
Reports last year were that dairy darmers in Kenya had seen their farm gate pricecs falling signficantly as a result of the aggressive Ugandan entrants.

Existing big interests in the Kenyan market then decided to use underhanded methods to frustrate Uganda processors. They are clearly very powerful interests as no official communication has been forthcoming about Uganda dairy exports.

This is a blatant breach of East Africa Community protocals that allow for the frfee movement of goods and services around the five countries, that Nairobi is unwilling or unable to enforce in the case of dairy exports.

The dairty of western Uganda find themselves caught in the middle crossfire that is none of their making, that threatens to derail Uganda's emergence of a continental dairy producing nation.

Exports from dairy products roped in $150m  in 2019, bettered only by gold and coffee in export receipts.

Tuesday, February 25, 2020

THE FATE OF PEARL DAIRY AND WHAT IT SAYS ABOUT THE EAST AFRICAN COMMUNITY


It can be frustrating even down right infuriating when you are in the midst of a historic movement. Progress or regression doesn’t happen in a straight line. You take two steps forward and one step back. Sometimes it’s worse, you take two steps forward and four steps back.

I have heard it said that we will take the class until we learn the lesson. And may I add, even if you think you have skipped the class and gone on, invariably one day you will come all the way back to take the class, so you can learn the lesson.

At the time of writing this the Presidents of Uganda and Rwanda are getting set for a border meeting at Katuna, which we all hope will lead to the reopening of the border and the free movement of goods and people.

Rwanda shut down the border a year ago ostensibly over the maltreatment of its people in Uganda.

"When our grandchildren will be reading history this border closure may occupy only a line in the greater scheme of things. Hopefully it will not have scuttled the greater goal of creating a single regional market....

There are more disturbing movements that affect Ugandan progress but also don’t bode well for the future of the EAC.

Ugandan sugar is having to jump through hoops to find its way into the Kenyan and Tanzanian markets. We are the only country in the community that is producing a surplus. Three decades of rehabilitation and expansion of our sugar firms has brought us to this happy situation.

In our eastern neighbour the sugar industry is all but dead, with the major sugar producing regions in western Kenya, brought to its knees by a combination of bad policy and the growing strength of sugar importing cartels. Uganda’s sugar industry, I fear is under attack from similar forces.

Our neighbours cannot believe that we can produce so much sugar as we are exporting to them. They have sent delegations (per diems all around) here to verify our capacity to produce. They have not found any foul play but have gone back and kept quiet allowing the charade to continue.

Our grain is being shipped across the border raw. Attempts to export maize flour have suffered uncalled for speed bumps and roadblocks. The message is clear, send us your raw materials but not your finished products. And we all know who benefits from such an arrangement.

More recently our milk producers, Pearl Dairies, the maker s of Lato milk, came up against some strange “official” resistance to their exports to Kenya. Their warehouses were raided and their stock impounded at the end of last year. Kenyan authorities unofficially charged that they were counterfeit supplies, strange because Pearl Diaries were not the ones complaining. But maybe that was because it was their milk.

But one can see what has happened. Last year Uganda exported in excess of 110 million liters of milk to Kenya, which helped for the first time since anyone remembers, to turn the balance of trade in our favour. This was particularly surprising because the previous year we had only exported about 20 million liters to our eastern cousins.

In the space of two and half years, by the end of last year, Pearl Dairy controlled about a quarter of the Kenyan milk market. That must have rustled a few feathers, especially that Pearl Dairies with their 800,000-liter day processing capacity in Ntungamo was not about to let up.

Then the stories begun again. Uganda is getting milk from Australia landing it in Kinshasa, trucking it through South Sudan before it comes to Kampala for reconstitution (adding water) and shipped to Kenya. If milk can go through that convoluted journey and still price competitively in the Kenyan market, then the Kenyan dairy industry has only themselves to blame.

Strangely, or not, other exporters of milk to Kenya from Uganda are not suffering such inconveniences or whisper campaigns.

We should be concerned.

One of the biggest selling points of the EAC on paper, is that investors can come and locate their plants wherever they choose in the region and have unfettered access to a 200 million people market.
The way it seems that’s for everybody else except Uganda.

If you have $50m to invest, like Pearl Dairies has done and want to invest in Uganda to exploit the EAC market, don’t bother.

Which is sad.

It does not take a stretch of imagination to workout that in order to fulfill its 84 million litre exports to Kenya, like they did last year, there must be hundreds of farmers in the Ntungamo area and hence thousands of their dependents in whose best interests it is to have the plant there working at full capacity. At the height of production last they inject at least sh12b into the local economy every moth.

Beyond that there are transporters, retailers, people up and down the value chain that want, no, need Pearl Dairy to remain in production.

But maybe we shouldn’t be surprised. It is no myth that Uganda’s agricultural potential is unmatched in the region. Our benign weather and arable soils mean that we are potentially the lowest cost producer of anything agricultural.

"Kenyan industry, which took advantage of the chaos of the 1970s and 80s, kept us a captive market for everything from toilet paper to sauce pans are fast waking up to an uncomfortable reality....

The lesson of the EAC obviously is that government needs to investigate in its negotiating capacity.  It can’t be for individual companies to be negotiating for market access, this is the business and role of governments.

Especially in our case where we have been the foremost champions of the creation of the EAC.


Tuesday, January 7, 2020

MILK, SUGAR AND THE CHANGING EAST AFRICA ECONOMY


It was an interesting coincidence that 10 years since the East Africa Customs Union came into force, a Kenyan delegation was in Uganda a few weeks ago, to help resolve a trade spurt between our two countries.

At issue was the surge in milk exports to Kenya from Uganda, which had halved farmgate prices in our eastern neighbor and made some powerful constituencies very jittery.

The price collapse in the Kenyan dairy market was prompted by a near sevenfold jump in milk exports from Uganda. Last year according to official figures Uganda exported 110 million liters of milk to Kenya from 16 million liters the previous year.

It is safe to say our neighbours have seen nothing yet.

The Dairy Development Authority reported in June last year that in 2017/18, milk production stood at 2.5 billion liters. Of this only a third of the milk or about 800 million liters is processed.

So if Kenyans have got their undies in a twist about 110 million liters, what would happen if we processed 50% of our production and exported the extra 400 million liters their way?

This was one of the best business stories of last year. The surge in exports overturned our trade balance in Kenya for the first time ever, with us exporting more to them than we import from them. It vindicates the champions of regional free trade...

The Kenyans are pondering slapping 16% VAT on our milk to give their embattled dairy farmers a chance. Which is good politics, but bad economics.

One of the main benefits of free trade is that it sharpens competitive advantages, the ability to produce something better than your competitors, which is a good thing.

The most efficient producers of a good or service end up thriving and the less competitive ones go off to look for their niche, what they can produce better than everybody else in the market.

There will be casualties of course, especially of those refusing to adapt to the changing times.

The anti-market lobby like to say that this is a bad trend and government should step in to subvert the market every so often. Often times the ones fronting this argument are those caught on the wrong side of the competition who want a government bailout.

The best way to look at it is to think of Uganda and its 100-plus districts. Imagine if we had, hard district borders, with customs posts at every district boundary.

To get matooke from Isingiro to Kampala currently, your main impediment is the state of the lorry carrying the matooke. There are no real tariff barriers between Isingiro and Kampala.

But if they were hard borders the inconvenience in crossing the nine district borders to get to Kampala, the time spent – a trip that probably took 10 hours would now be drawn out over a week, and the costs in import levies, overnight travel, would make a bunch of matooke so expensive that Kampala would start growing its own matooke.

The Kampala soils are nowhere near the quality of those in Isingiro, so the people of the capital city would settle for lesser quality food because of these barriers to trade. Kampala will be forced to indulge in an activity it’s white and blue collar workers have no competitive advantage in.

"The net effect of this would be a lower standard of living for city dwellers, than if the district boundaries were brought down....

The East African Community is bringing this reality to the fore.

In 2019 Kenyan farmers have complained not only about Ugandan milk but Ugandan sugar, grain and even poultry. The hard border and Uganda’s years of instability in the 1970s and 1980s allowed less efficient Kenyan producers operate. With stability and the Uganda economy back on a growth path, the Kenyan farmer is being reminded that there are more efficient producers on the other side of the border.

But you can expect that the interest groups who have invested their lives in this inefficient arrangement will not roll over and die. They will fight long and hard to maintain the status quo. But as they say, there is nothing more powerful than an idea whose time has come.

In Uganda too, some of our producers will have to face up to this new reality. Those who were sucked into the whole import substitution drive will be the hardest hit. There are somethings we have no business trying to produce, because the Kenyans produce it cheaper or even further afield, the Chinese, with their massive economies of scale can produce and land it on our shores, for a fraction of the price that either of us can produce it at.

"Some cynics would argue that agriculture is not the way to develop modern societies, but that would be to ignore the experience of Denmark or New Zealand. This is also to not appreciate the scope of agro-industries that can be built around research, processing, logistics, marketing, retail, hospitality and, that we haven’t even begun to scratch the surface of our true potential....

The government rather than side with entrenched interest groups or crony capitalists needs to direct our economy towards the production of that, that we have a competitive advantage in. When we have mustered enough capacity and surpluses, we can tinker around in areas where we can develop some competence, eventually.

And by the way more than two decades ago the United Nations Development Program (UNDP) mapped out a strategy based on the industries that we have or can develop a real competitive advantage in, at least in the region.

These were agriculture, tourism, services – education, health, financial and ICT and mining. Twenty years later and we are just waking up to our agricultural potential.

Friday, September 27, 2019

NSSF ANNOUNCES 11PCT INTEREST ON MEMBER SAVINGS



KAMPALA – Uganda’s National Social Security Fund (NSSF) on Friday announced that it would pay out an 11 percent interest on members savings, down from last year’s 15 percent but above their commitment to pay more than the average inflation rate of the last 10 years.

In 2014/15 NSSF pledged to pay two percentage point s or above the 10-year average inflation rate. The average inflation rate for the last 10 years is 6.7 percent.

This is the lowest interest payment by the Fund since the 10 percent given to members in 2012.
The lower rate came as a result of unrealized losses on their equity holdings during the year exchange losses on their investments abroad.

The local and regional stock exchanges on which the Fund is heavily invested showed double digit losses in their performance last year. The Uganda Securities Exchange shed 10 percent of its value, the Nairobi Securities exchange 14 percent and the Dar es Salaam Stock Exchange 21 percent. NSSF reported a sh168.9b unrealized loss from its equity holdings.

NSSF’s regional and international portfolio also suffered a sh247b foreign exchange loss as the Uganda shilling uncharacteristically strengthen against the US dollar and regional currencies.

These two losing items accounted for the entire sh404.9b loss that the Fund announced for the year. Last year NSSF reported a sh240.4b surplus.

As a result, NSSF paid out sh978b or 11 percent less in interest to its members than last year’s 1,100b.

The loss came despite a 21 percent jump in total revenues to sh1,255b from sh1,042b.

END


Wednesday, September 18, 2019

NSSF'S CHALLENGE IS THAT OF UGANDA

Uganda's National Social Security Fund (NSSF) reported a sh405b loss for the year that ended in June 2019 on the back of unrealised losses on their equity positions and foreign exchange losses.

Last year the Fund reported a sh240b surplus for the year which prompted them to pay out a record 15 percent interest on member savings. NSSF has said they will announce the new interest rate at the member meeting on 27th September but they have warned that, understandably, they will not match last year's rate.

Their accounts show they will be paying out sh978b in interest this year to their members down 11 percent from last year's sh1.1trillion.

They are confident that they will beat a promise they made to their members five years ago that they will pay out at least two percentage points overt he 10 year average inflationary rate. The average inflationary rate of the last ten years was 6.7 percent.

A cursory look over their accounts shows that entire loss was attributable to fair value losses on their investments of sh169b and currency losses of sh247b for a total loss of sh416b, variables not really under the management's control.

Interestingly their dividend income sh77b was up 45 percent from last year's sh53b. Interest income was up 19 percent with rental income slipping marginally to sh10.7b  from sh10.9b the previous year.

The telling detail is that only 6.82 percent of the dividend income comes from Uganda. This is interesting because whereas all the regional bourses in which NSSF has an interest in all suffered double digit losses during the period under consideration, the Uganda Securities Exchange (USE) was down the least. So if our equity holdings were biased towards the USE instead of Kenya there would be less of a loss.

And that is the challenge and one governments needs to stop sidestepping and address squarely. NSSF does not invest abroad leaving opportunities begging in its backyard, it invests abroad for lack of opportunities at home.

As has been mentioned earlier its portfolio is biased heavily towards government debt, in fact of all government's bond issues NSSF holds 40 percent and it is also the biggest holder of outstanding shares on the USE.

Government needs to actively encourage our biggest companies to list on the USE, which would, at the bare minimum, reduce NSSF's foreign exchange risk. Some estimates have it that the market capitalisation on the USE can more than double over the next five years if the government took a proactive stand on the issue.

The counter argument is that last year the fund made sh313b in currency gains. Ironically the losses came about because the Uganda shilling this year fared better not only against the US dollar, but also the Rwanda Franc, the Kenya and Tanzanian Shilling. An anomaly seen against its record over the last several years.

The benefits that would come with a more vibrant capital market, it can be argued too far outweigh the currency gains that would be made investing abroad. Those gains are not permanent as this last year has shown.

This being as it is, it still raises questions about NSSF's asset mix. As it stands now 79 percent is in fixed income, mostly government paper, 15 percent in equity and six percent in real estate.

It was not all doom and gloom for the Fund though. Total revenues were up 20 percent to sh1.25trillion from last year's sh1.04trillion. Its assets under management were up 13 percent to sh11.3trillion from sh9.9trillion. During the same period the economy grew by six percent. And the Fund was able to cut its expenses to assets to 1.28 percent from 1.31 percent the previous year.

Every so often the Fund's asset allocation throws up a surprise but on the whole NSSF is doing the best it can -- given the circumstances.








Monday, April 8, 2019

WHY KENYA, UGANDA RELATIONS ARE KEY TO EAC


Last week President Museveni paid a state visit to Kenya on the invitation of his counterpart Uhuru Kenyatta.

It made sense that Museveni would overfly the capital Nairobi to start the visit in the Mombasa, the de facto gate way to the region. According to port authorities in 2017 Uganda accounted for almost a quarter of all trade through the port. Seven million tons out of a total of 30.35 tons of cargo that pass through Mombasa were registered to Uganda.

Museveni eventually went to Nairobi, riding on the Standard Gauge Railway (SGR) first leg.
During the visit a series of agreements to allow greater access of Ugandan – sugar, dairy and poultry products and Kenyan goods – beef in the respective countries were signed off. The intention to lease 
Uganda land to build a dry port in Naivasha, one of the terminal’s of the SGR was also announced.

"Before Tanzania came under British mandate after the First World War it was just present day Kenya and Uganda, stitched together by the Uganda Railway, which had landed in Kisumu in 1901. A steamer service led to the construction of an 11 km line from Port Bell to Kampala. The line via Malaba to Kampala was completed in 1931.

The real core of the east African community is Uganda and Kenya, where the trade figures between the two countries is concrete evidence of their symbiosis.

In 2017 trade between the two countries stood at more than a billion dollars. A similar figure for trade between Kenya and Tanzania is about $500m.

It is clear that our relation is not based on sentimentality. Even during the 1970s when diplomatic relations were at their lowest, trade continue along the common border and over Lake Victoria, that once relations normalized was easily reformalised in the 1980s.

If there is one country that has provided sustainable economic benefit to Uganda it has to be Kenya. Their demand for food alone is slowly transforming our agriculture from the limbo of subsistence it has been stuck in to more commercial enterprise.

We have had a few moments of madness in the past.

In 1976 Idi Amin decided it might be a good idea to revisit an old map of the region which had the Ugandan border starting at the Kenyan Rift Valley.  Kenya’s Jomo Kenyatta – father of the current president, massed his troops on our common border and swore, “Wacha ajaribu, atatutambua!” (Let him try and he will find out who we are).

A second time was at the end of 1987 when there was shoot out at the Busia border, that led to a border shut down for a few weeks. Both countries traded accusations with Uganda accusing Kenya of habouring anti-government rebels and Kenya claiming its neighbours troops had crossed onto their side.

Speculation mostly unproven, was that Kenyan commercial interests were unimpressed about noises from Kampala pushing for a resuscitation of our industrial capacity so as to wean ourselves away from Kenya’s manufacturers. Kisumu’s industry built up during the 1970s was targeted at supplying Uganda.

In both instances sanity prevailed quickly because there were real economic interests at stake beyond brotherly love.

"It has been proven time and time again, that trade relations are the more sustainable glue that holds communities together and prevent wars...

The Europeans put a stop to centuries of fratricidal conflict after the second world war, with the creation of the European Coal and Steel Community, the precursor to the current European Union, which has allowed the free movement of goods, service and people.

This has had the effect of creating specialisations, with countries doing away with what they cannot produce competitively, choosing to import what they don’t produce and export their surpluses. This interdependence means war or even diplomatic rows have little fuel to sustain them.

The opening up of our markets will come with some short term pain as some industries are outcompeted by more efficient ones across the border, as is already happening. But as suggested above it will sharpen our businessmen’s sense of what they can produce competitively, so that they specialize, scale up their operations and gear up to supply our neighbour’s $75b economy’s needs.

There are those who will argue that our industries will need protection as they are still in their infancy, they will say that is how industries elsewhere survived. What they do not talk about is the opportunity cost in effort, resources – human and financial, that will be expended in ensuring that these uncompetitive industries stay afloat.

"If there are public funds to be spent they will be best employed helping uncompetitive companies retool or wind up, than subsidizing them to stay afloat, because as we have discovered they can’t seem to wean themselves off the subsidies once they have started to enjoy them...

The people of the two countries will be the eventual winners working for competitive sustainable companies and enjoying better goods and service in return.

Monday, April 1, 2019

BAT WIN IN EA COURT FOR ALL OF US


On Tuesday this week British American Tobacco Uganda (BAT) won a landmark case in the East Africa Court of Justice (EACJ) where they challenged the Uganda’s discriminative excise duty levy on goods manufactured outside Uganda but in the Community.

Some background will serve this story well.

In 2013 BAT wound up its cigarette manufacturing in Uganda, they had a plant in jinja. They then started importing cigarettes for distribution in Uganda from Kenya. In 2017 there was an amendment to the Excise Duty Act which required that Uganda Revenue Authority (URA) charged imported cigarettes more than the ones produced locally.

BAT challenged this successfully in a judgement that not only saw BAT receive a sh325m refund on taxes they had already paid, but also declared null and void any provisions in the law that are contrary to the EAC laws.

Kiryowa Kiwanuka of K & K Advocates, which represented BAT, said after the ruling, that the net effect of this is to make the EAC one country for tax purposes.

It was his opinion that manufacturers around the region will be forced to compete on the cost of production and distribution and not on tax levels.

Clearly this is an earth shaking precedent we probably missed because we were focused on imaginary assassins this week.

"It is a double edged sword.

On the one hand one can now expect that our products that were suffering arbitrary barriers to entry in the EAC like sugar and milk, that will be a thing of the past.

On the other hand there are products we are producing that face direct competition from companies in other member countries, some of which can be landed in Uganda cheaper than we produce them here...

With a level playing field they may very have to become more efficient or fold altogether.

So one can expect in the region there will be companies very in support of the new ruling --- the exporters and other companies for whom the new wave of imports will pose serious existential threats.

The principle of the common market is that there will be free movement of goods, services and people through the region. The common market will then be attractive for investors to make a bet on.

The community has a population of about 170 million at last count, of whom 34 million are urban dwellers.  These are just numbers unless the requisite infrastructure and enabling legislation is in place to allow for it to be one market.

The challenge then for individual countries would be their ability to attract the investors to their shores. If you are a country which is irredeemably corrupt, have port hole ridden roads and the quality of your workforce is imbecilic you will fare badly against your better endowed members, in terms of attracting investors.

However, the theorists argue that the improvement’s in living standards of the people from the increased trade will more than offset the loss of investment.

So for example if Uganda becomes the hub of grain production and production in the region, because it can produce at much lower cost that its neighbours, investors in the sector in Kenya and Tanzania will either have to shut down or relocate their capacity to Uganda. There will be job losses in Kenya and Tanzania but there will be some relief at the cheaper products on the shelf.

The workers though might find themselves in the absorbed in the soda ash industry. Soda ash – sodium carbonate, is only mined in southern Kenya, and is a compound in many industrial uses like dyes, ferterlisers and synthetic detergents. The Kenyan indsutry will have to ramp up production to serve all of the region and any other such operations elsewhere in the region would have to shut down.

One big advantage that would come with a full operation of the open market would be that individual countries would be forced to stick to their competitive advantages. There is no point why anyone else in the region should be trying to produce matooke other than Uganda for instance. This specialization will encourage efficiencies that can only make us stronger as a region.

"And that is why too the freedom of movement of goods and services has to go hand in hand with the ease of movement of people, because if I have just been laid off from a steel making plant in Uganda I should be able to relocate to Kenya to work in their plants...

Some people may think it unfortunate that its BAT that won the case, but the benefits of the ruling are not restricted to them. We can all benefit.

Tuesday, February 26, 2019

GOVT MUST GIVE ITS COMPANIES A CHANCE TO WORK


The recent Auditor General’s report was, as ever, an eye opener about how government its departments and authorities conduct their financial affairs.

It is mind boggling how parts of government get away with financial mismanagement year after year and nothing seems to be done to the responsible officials.

I was particularly interested in the state enterprises performance.

"Of the 24 state enterprises the Auditor General reported that just under half or 14 of the 29 enterprises showed a profit. For many the quality of the earnings didn’t stand up to scrutiny, when viewed against their asset bases, but that is a story for another day....

No details were given of the individual company accounts but one wondered how Uganda Electricity Generation Company ltd (UEGCL), Uganda Electricity Transmission Company Ltd (UETCL) and Uganda Electricity Distribution Company ltd (UEDCL) continue to be loss making.

The three companies are as a result of three way split of the former Uganda Electricity Board (UEB). The thinking was that the unbundling of the dinosaur would improve specialisation and make the component parts much easier to flog off to private operators.

So with Eskom taking over the Kiira and Nalubale dams and Umeme taking over the power distribution, UEGCL and UEDCL remained as custodians of the assets that the government had leased to the private players. The transmission function remained with government.

You are loss making when your expenses exceed your revenues. In that case you are not making enough money --- often a failing of the marketing department or your costs are unrealistically high.

The financials of UETCL and UEDCL were not available online.

But UEGCL’s numbers were and they showed that the company earned income from the concession fees paid to it by the operators of power generation plants and some grants. I suspect this is the same for the other two entities.

Depreciation and amortisation is the greatest expense, wiping out UEGCL’s entire income. When you add on staff and admin costs it sinks UEGCL further in the red.

So either UEGCL’s is not pricing its services well enough or costs have run amok.

"As it turns out UEGCL is not allowed to charge depreciation on the assets in the concession – dams, which it owns. The depreciation they booked was for assets that were used to supervise the projects and not on the fixed assets like the dams...

While if fully provided for this would sink UEGCL further in the red, adding it to the portion of the tariff due to UEGCL would increase their top line considerably.

More importantly it would mean these would be funds the company would revert to, to finance other hydro-power developments. Depreciation is not paid out but retained in the company to at least finance replacement of existing assets.

But one can understand the logic of removing these charges from the books. It artificially keeps the tariff low but compromises the ability of UEGCL or the other companies to carry out their mandate sustainably...

What it means that under the current arrangement for all subsequent power plant developments UEGCL will have to fall at the feet of government to provide the required funds, unnecessary if they were allowed to charge for it.

Given the government’s shifting priorities this is not an ideal situation for any manager to be in.
It’s no surprise then that government is now resorting to expensive loans to finance its power expansion ambitions. A classic case of the chicken coming home to roost. Because it seems expedient to bury our head in the sand and keep tariffs artificially low, this short sightedness then comes back to bite us and actually hampers the appropriate roll out of new power plants in the future.

This year the 183 MW Isimba and the 600 MW Karuma power projects are coming on line and one can expect that government will continue with this pattern of doing things in attempt to keep tariffs low.

We have a set target to increase power generation to 17000 MW by 2028, this means that under the current arrangement UEGCL will be unable to budget to build or cooperate in the building of new plants unless government provides the funds.

We can expect the convoluted process to construct Isimba and Karuma to played out in subsequent power generation projects because UEGCL’s has its hands tied.

Essentially what government is doing is not allowing UEGCL to succeed. It is hard to see how the company will break even under the current circumstances and therefore compromise its capacity to fulfil its mandate...

As I said I couldn’t see the financials of the other two companies but it would come as no surprise if they are treated the same.

And one last thing that unlike other Independent Power Producers (IPP), UEGCL is not allowed to add a Return on Equity (ROE) to their portion of the tariff. Again for the reason that it would raise the tariff to uncomfortable levels. This too hobbles UEGCL’s long-time viability and usefulness to the country.

"Across the border in Kenya UEGCL’s counterpart KENGEN relies on its own resources to expand power generation. It is no wonder that KENGEN, a profitable company in its own right, has greater generation capacity than Uganda despite our greater potential to generate power – at least hydro-electric power...

Must Read

BOOK REVIEW: MUSEVENI'S UGANDA; A LEGACY FOR THE AGES

The House that Museveni Built: How Yoweri Museveni’s Vision Continues to Shape Uganda By Paul Busharizi  On sale HERE on Amazon (e-book...