Monday, March 2, 2015

OUR SECURITY IS TOO IMPORTANT TO BE LEFT TO THE POLICE



Tomorrow Saturday, February 28th Inspector General of Police Major General Kale Kaihura will be leading hundreds of runners through the hills of Ibanda in attempt to raise awareness about the benefits of community policing.

The inaugural run will be contested over 5-, 12- and 21-km, funds from the event will go towards the welfare of the 900 crime preventers in the area. The recruitment of crime preventers in local communities was an initiative by the police to augment their own capacity in preventing and detecting crime. The crime preventers are volunteers who are taught basic policing skills to help secure their respective communities.

In 2013 about 100,000 criminal cases were reported to the police a marginal decrease from the previous year, but seen in a different perspective, one criminal case avoided is one less person living in fear.


"Of course all crime is not reported and it’s probably a compliment to the police that people even report crimes to them, a sign probably of growing confidence in the force by the public...


Better manned, better equipped and better facilitated than a decade ago the police presence cannot be ignored.

However even if there were police men patrolling at every street corner they would not take away the role of popular vigilance, the determination by the very society they police to look out for crime and play an active role in preventing and aiding in the apprehension of offenders.

They say there is no secret between two people. For every crime committed someone knows something either before it is committed or after the fact. If the right reporting structures are put in place imagine how dramatically the crime levels can fall.

Beyond that the initiative is being driven by the private sector and spearheaded by the police. The people who stand to lose the most by an escalation in insecurity are the business community. They would have to incur higher costs to secure their business and also have to factor in the cost of uncertainty that comes with insecurity or pack up their business and take them elsewhere or wait out the cycle of insecurity.

The irony is that since the insecurity is often caused by restless, jobless youth, a slow down or shuttering of businesses denies the youth the very jobs that would keep them out of trouble. A vicious cycle.


"Its good to see businessmen putting aside their daily rivalries to try and solve a community problem that if resolved would benefit everyone...


However we have to always guard against them doing it to obtain some leverage over our government institutions. The police budget is channeled through the consolidated fund. However it does not take a genius to recognise that the police remain woefully underfunded.

The funds from these and future runs will go mainly to beefing up the community policing capacity – the crime preventers and constructing police booths for instance. This money should be monitored and accounted for so that it goes to the purpose it is meant, if only to maintain public confidence in the partnership.

And finally there is a way for the public to contribute to these kind of endeavors in a more structured way.

The police can borrow from the public using the bond markets. People are always weary of increasing public debt – the debt contracted by government and its institutions from the public, but if there is one thing we have learnt in the last 30 years is that without security nothing matters.

It is by the grace of God that crime rates are not higher in Uganda, given how badly the police is facilitated, but we shouldn’t wait for all hell to break loose before we make a move.

The Ibanda Marathon is a good initiative that should be supported and rolled out in other districts in Uganda.

Tuesday, February 24, 2015

IT’S NOT GREEK! WHAT IS HAPPENING TO GREECE CAN HAPPEN TO US


While we have been preoccupied with our internal politics Greece has been teethering at the edge of economic disaster.

Imagine you inherit a house in Kololo, with a 25 meter pool, a fantastic lawn and garden, 50 bulb-house and a staff complement of five. After the initial euphoria of living in Kololo has worn off (probably by the time of the first workers’ paycheck) it will begin to dawn on you that you might be playing out of your league.

But you might soldier on thinking that you have arrived because you live in Kololo.

You will soon realise too that to keep up with your neighbours your security lights have to be on all night, you have to own a fuel guzzling 4wd – not one, but at least two, one for you and one for your better half, you might have to throw a few garden parties, if only to “revenge” for the ones you have been invited to.

You soon realise that the expenses are mounting faster than your boss can afford you a raise.

You can do one of two things. Either, sell the house or rent it out and move to a neighbourhood where you can keep up with the Jones, better still where you can be THE Jones or raid your bank, the local loan shark, friends and family to keep up the lifestyle.

The latter is the more sensible solution but oftentimes, out of pride and our unwillingness to take a downgrade to our new lifestyle, we opt for the second.

Before not long debt payments catch up with you and suddenly the walls around your compound serve as a prison. That is if your better half is not insisting on sustaining the fictitious standard of living – at least outside your compound here people can see you making a retreat behind the walls less than a pleasant experience.

By the end of the day you may lose your inheritance, your family and your pride as the debt collectors give you no breathing space within which to manoeuvre.

That in a nut shell is what happened to Greece.

It was invited to the European Community in 1981 and 20 years later join the Eurozone, the group of western European countries that use the Euro as their currency.

With that the Greeks embarked on a huge public spending spree – of course to keep up with their wealthier European neighbours, the spruced up their infrastructure, paid for an extremely expensive Olympic Games in 2004 and raised public service salaries by as much as 50%.

"Things may have worked had the global financial crisis not rolled in in 2008 and exposed how the Greeks were living way beyond their means. As if that was not enough they were hiding debt off the books and tax evasion is a national past time. Which was a double whammy because not only were their repayments mounting but their taxes collections could not honour their obligations...

If they were a person, Greece would long have been declared bankrupt and their assets parcelled out to willing buyers to pay off their debtors.

But Greece is a country – and thankfully not Uganda, so they were bailed out twice in 2010 and 2014, with conditions attached. Among  the conditions were that they would collect more tax, privatise their public enterprises and cut down on public spending.

Politics did not allow them live up to the conditions and in fact in January the Greeks voted in a government that had pledged to throw out these austerity measures and tell the EU to jump in the Mediterranean.

By the time of writing this column a Friday deadline was looming. The Greeks had blinked earlier in the week and suggested they may accept some extension to the debt. Germany, the EU’s economic loadstone, said without accepting the full conditions for another bailout they would veto any rescue plan.

However observers were already saying it would not be as much of a tragedy if the Greeks left he EU as compared to the last two times. Previously they owed a lot of private banks money, defaulting on the debt would have infected the rest of Europe. Now the debt -- €320b (sh1,070b)  or four times the size of the  East African Community economy is owed  mostly to governments, who are better placed to survive a collapse.

"It is easy to see how they got to where they are. There are only two ways to spend money to consume it or to invest it. The latter gives you a good chance of ending rich, the former is guaranteed to pauperise you...

The Greeks are learning the hard way.

Monday, February 23, 2015

JANANI LUWUM: LET’S PLEDGE “NEVER AGAIN!”


Last week we commemorated the death of Archbishop Janani Luwum, who was killed in February 16, 1977 following allegations he was collaborating with the forces opposed to then president Idi Amin.

The official record is that he was killed during interrogation, but there is a strong suspicion that Amin himself may have actually pulled the trigger himself.

We read how attempts to portray Luwum’s death as a car accident didn’t hold. One nurse from Mulago testified that she saw bullet holes on his neck and chest, while another reported that a badly beaten Luwum joined other inmates briefly in the cells of the State Research Bureau (SRB) in Nakasero ours before his death.

During it all the good Archbishop does not seem to have lose his poise or lost his faith in his God. A useful study courage, defined as grace under pressure.

Reconstructing the mood of the time does not take a fertile imagination.


"An isolated Amin, by this time six years into his reign of terror, was seeing opponents – real and imagined around every corner. Either because of his limited exposure to the structures of civil society or because of a total disregard for due process or because he could, he and his system were eliminating people on pure suspicion....


The terror was made all the more universal, the anecdotal evidence suggests, with some people taking advantage of the situation to settle personal scores, to grab property or take over people’s girlfriends and wives.

Clearly Luwum fell prey to this heightened sense of paranoia, whether he sympathised with the opponents of Amin’s clumsy administration or not.

It has been suggested that the death of Luwum was the straw that broke the camel’s back, finally raising international awareness to the extent of how things had gone wrong in Uganda and galvanising support for regime change in Kampala.

Looking back almost 40 years it is maybe hard to fathom how things came to that.

A younger person in his 30s who ardently followed the series of articles on the Vision Group’s various platforms, leading up to the commemoration on Monday, was in genuine shock while declaring, “So Amin was this bad?”

Shock because in his experience it would be inconceivable for a senior prelate in such and secondly that a president would be personally involved (that is what he is convinced happened) in such an act.

It is probably that same naïvete that allowed Amin to run rough shod over the population and by the time people had got over their gullibility and stopped giving him the benefit of doubt, they were paralysed with terror and unable to mount any meaningful opposition internally.

It is useful to celebrate the life of Luwum, even make it a public holiday, but he would have died in vain if we do not look beyond the horror of the time to understand how the situation degenerated to such depths.

We can blame it on the politics.

Our post-independence politicians in trying to outmaneuver each other resorted to extrajudicial methods, circumventing established institutions and generally setting precedents that continue to reverberate down our history.

Once the powers that be begun to ignore the laws to ensure they got their way, they had begun the slide down a very slippery slope into chaos.

By February 1977 anything could go.

Agency or the role of an individual or group of people in shaping events will always be critical in the unfolding of history, but the sustainability of those changes or their continued progress, will depend on the viability of the society’s institutions.

Maybe one can’t fault a young independent Uganda whose institutions had not matured enough as to call the main actors to order at the time.

Maybe our major players were just inherently averse to operating in structured situations and preferred fluid situations where the ends justified the means and to hell with the rest.

Maybe we can blame fate that a coincidence of events that did not happen in neighbouring Kenya or Tanzania happened here and the problems of the 1970s and 1980s were predestined.


"They say that those that do not learn from history are bound to repeat the mistakes of the past. It offers no solace that they also say that, what we learn from history is that we do not learn from history...


Hence the importance of a deeper commemoration of Luwum’s death.

Thousands of people died during that horrific eight years of our history, and as inconceivable as it seems we can return to such a time unless we internalise and learn from what led to that dark age and determine that “Never Again!”

Wednesday, February 18, 2015

AID NEEDS TO BE RECONFIGURED TO BENEFIT THE RECIPIENTS


Last week three articles in the local and international press caught my eye.

In our very own New Vision former finance minister and now Uganda Revenue Authority (URA) Gerald Sendaula repeated the sad fact that we pay too little tax as a proportion of our economic output – 11%. He suggests that land should be taxed to bridge this gap. He pointed out that whereas agriculture, which is based on land, accounted for three in every ten shillings of GDP it accounted for less than one percent of tax collections. 

The other article was in the Economist, which lamented that since the Haiti earthquake in 2010, when the country was literally flattened, there is little real improvement to show for the $9.5b (sh27trillion) outpouring of charity that gushed into the Caribbean island state.

An important point made in the article was because of the endemic corruption in Haiti’s bureaucracy the aid agents circumvented the government to get to the recipients. However this had the unintended consequence of not exercising the institutions, so now those same neglected institutions cannot ensure continuity of some of the projects the donors left behind like health centers and water purifying plants.

And finally across the border from us host, President Paul Kagame told the East African Capital Markets Conference held in Kigali.

“The question of preference between markets and aid can only be asked in Africa, not in any other region of this world. Let’s not be diplomatic, let’s not gloss over issues. Markets are markets. We know what they offer outweigh what we have in aid by thousands of times. All kinds of wealth lying all over the place in Africa and being recycled to us in forms of aid and in the end we are told, you must be humble and quiet and not say anything. Let’s not be diplomatic, let’s not gloss over issues. Markets are markets. We know what they offer outweigh what we have in aid by thousand of times.
Aid is more political than anything else. Markets are less political, they are neutral.”


In the first instance we see that we actually have the capacity to raise much more tax in this country, but we don’t. And that the aid industry we have been seduced to think is willing to bail us out, actually does us little good. And finally that aid is about exerting political influence and less about doing any good for the real recipients of this aid....


We really need no convincing about these facts in Uganda.

For instance despite the massive amounts of money poured into the health and education setcors, judging by their results in terms of increased school dropouts and poor facilities, it’s hard to make a reasonable value-for-money justification for the received funds.

But for a fraction of the same cost the private sector has resuscitated commerce and industry and their taxes, which have risen a hundredfold in the last three decades, have ensured a much improved Uganda. Which is not saying very much, but at least significant improvement has been recorded.

The Haitian experience was inevitable for a number of well-known reasons.

One, that a lot of aid is often lost in administrative costs – those four wheel drive monsters and the expatriates who whiz around in them don’t come cheap. And secondly, these aid workers totally oblivious to the local context often get the project designs so wrong that they are unusable after they have upped and left.

And finally aid agencies not unlike governments, are more concerned with the inputs – classrooms built, clinics kitted and boreholes sunk that the actual output in terms of real sustainable improvements in the living standards of the beneficiary communities.

But what if we tapped the markets for our financing needs? Oh no! The donor experts will say, it will burst your borrowing limits and make your debt unsustainable.

A valid concern but only if we are going to splurge on luxury imports and white  elephants like stadiums, palatial state houses and fleets of fuel guzzling 4WDs for our officials. If however we are going to spend that money on generating electricity, sprucing up our telecom networks, laying more tarmac road or building railways and opening up water ways, such projects will generate economic activity and pay their way.

Beyond that the markets that lend us this money will verify the viability of the projects and lend if there is a real business case for them. Because the markets would rather be paid than chase down their debt from reluctant borrowers. Not all the time, but enough times to ensure a critical mass of these projects wlll come in, on time, under budget and live a lasting impression.


"One of two things have to change. Either the aid industry changes the way they do business to, for instance the many billions remain in the beneficiary communities in a sustainable way, which is unlikely soon.

Or we rethink the way we think about markets and recognise that they have something we want and we have something they want. A mutually beneficial relationship...


The second part can be helped when we realise that we are actually a rich country, a rich continent not only because of the value under the soil or the industriousness of our people but also because the evidence is there that we have supported and helped the west thrive, first through slavery and cheap raw materials and increasingly now via net outflows from our countries, although official figures show we are aid recipients.

Must Read

BOOK REVIEW: MUSEVENI'S UGANDA; A LEGACY FOR THE AGES

The House that Museveni Built: How Yoweri Museveni’s Vision Continues to Shape Uganda By Paul Busharizi  On sale HERE on Amazon (e-book...