Wednesday, February 18, 2015

AID NEEDS TO BE RECONFIGURED TO BENEFIT THE RECIPIENTS


Last week three articles in the local and international press caught my eye.

In our very own New Vision former finance minister and now Uganda Revenue Authority (URA) Gerald Sendaula repeated the sad fact that we pay too little tax as a proportion of our economic output – 11%. He suggests that land should be taxed to bridge this gap. He pointed out that whereas agriculture, which is based on land, accounted for three in every ten shillings of GDP it accounted for less than one percent of tax collections. 

The other article was in the Economist, which lamented that since the Haiti earthquake in 2010, when the country was literally flattened, there is little real improvement to show for the $9.5b (sh27trillion) outpouring of charity that gushed into the Caribbean island state.

An important point made in the article was because of the endemic corruption in Haiti’s bureaucracy the aid agents circumvented the government to get to the recipients. However this had the unintended consequence of not exercising the institutions, so now those same neglected institutions cannot ensure continuity of some of the projects the donors left behind like health centers and water purifying plants.

And finally across the border from us host, President Paul Kagame told the East African Capital Markets Conference held in Kigali.

“The question of preference between markets and aid can only be asked in Africa, not in any other region of this world. Let’s not be diplomatic, let’s not gloss over issues. Markets are markets. We know what they offer outweigh what we have in aid by thousands of times. All kinds of wealth lying all over the place in Africa and being recycled to us in forms of aid and in the end we are told, you must be humble and quiet and not say anything. Let’s not be diplomatic, let’s not gloss over issues. Markets are markets. We know what they offer outweigh what we have in aid by thousand of times.
Aid is more political than anything else. Markets are less political, they are neutral.”


In the first instance we see that we actually have the capacity to raise much more tax in this country, but we don’t. And that the aid industry we have been seduced to think is willing to bail us out, actually does us little good. And finally that aid is about exerting political influence and less about doing any good for the real recipients of this aid....


We really need no convincing about these facts in Uganda.

For instance despite the massive amounts of money poured into the health and education setcors, judging by their results in terms of increased school dropouts and poor facilities, it’s hard to make a reasonable value-for-money justification for the received funds.

But for a fraction of the same cost the private sector has resuscitated commerce and industry and their taxes, which have risen a hundredfold in the last three decades, have ensured a much improved Uganda. Which is not saying very much, but at least significant improvement has been recorded.

The Haitian experience was inevitable for a number of well-known reasons.

One, that a lot of aid is often lost in administrative costs – those four wheel drive monsters and the expatriates who whiz around in them don’t come cheap. And secondly, these aid workers totally oblivious to the local context often get the project designs so wrong that they are unusable after they have upped and left.

And finally aid agencies not unlike governments, are more concerned with the inputs – classrooms built, clinics kitted and boreholes sunk that the actual output in terms of real sustainable improvements in the living standards of the beneficiary communities.

But what if we tapped the markets for our financing needs? Oh no! The donor experts will say, it will burst your borrowing limits and make your debt unsustainable.

A valid concern but only if we are going to splurge on luxury imports and white  elephants like stadiums, palatial state houses and fleets of fuel guzzling 4WDs for our officials. If however we are going to spend that money on generating electricity, sprucing up our telecom networks, laying more tarmac road or building railways and opening up water ways, such projects will generate economic activity and pay their way.

Beyond that the markets that lend us this money will verify the viability of the projects and lend if there is a real business case for them. Because the markets would rather be paid than chase down their debt from reluctant borrowers. Not all the time, but enough times to ensure a critical mass of these projects wlll come in, on time, under budget and live a lasting impression.


"One of two things have to change. Either the aid industry changes the way they do business to, for instance the many billions remain in the beneficiary communities in a sustainable way, which is unlikely soon.

Or we rethink the way we think about markets and recognise that they have something we want and we have something they want. A mutually beneficial relationship...


The second part can be helped when we realise that we are actually a rich country, a rich continent not only because of the value under the soil or the industriousness of our people but also because the evidence is there that we have supported and helped the west thrive, first through slavery and cheap raw materials and increasingly now via net outflows from our countries, although official figures show we are aid recipients.

Tuesday, February 17, 2015

THE UNWHOLESOME PRESSURE WE PUT ON OUR CHILDREN



Last week 23 year old Joan Abua, frustrated with her third O-levels failure, committed suicide by hanging herself from a tree behind the family home in Akongo village, Otuke district.

In letters she left behind for her family, she lamented, “This world is not easy, I tried my best in vain” and while thanking people for coming to her funeral, she promised to curse her relatives if the letters were not read out for the mourners.

Around the country similar dramatics were played out – with far less fatal consequences, by “failed” candidates. 

One boy, crushed that he did not get four-in-four at primary level, retreated to his room and refused to come out until his parents had wangled a position in a high flying secondary school. He had scored four distinctions. 

Another young lady who was hell bent on a career in medicine was so distraught that there was a chance she might not do it in Makerere University, she was ready to repeat her A-levels to make sure of it in 2016. Never mind that she had AAC.


But back to Joan.

"There is something very wrong when a young adult gives up hope and takes their life. 


At that age, people should feel that they have the world at their feet, that they are indestructible and that their futures are blindingly bright...


That she repeated her O-levels multiple times points to the fallacy that success in life, which we equate to financial success, flows from academic achievement. And only from a specific education, the one that leads to professional qualifications.

We are involved in one big conspiracy, where the emphasis of our education system is to obtain good marks and not to teach us how to learn, which was the original intent of education.

Which makes sense because documented knowledge was limited then, relative to the current situation, so learning was intended to encourage an inquiring mind, a mind straining against the boundaries of known knowledge.

"What is happening now is that, as a means to market our institutions, we are putting our kids under pressure to churn out four-in-fours and eight-in-eights by cramming information into their little heads and sucking the joy of childhood out of them with loads of homework and ungodly school hours. The unintended consequence of this being that we are graduating self-absorbed, zombies that are good for regurgitating what they have learnt but struggle in the real world where everything is in a constant state of flux....

Essentially we are setting our children up for failure.

Robert Kiyosaki author of the book Rich Dad, Poor Dad says that A-student end up working for C- students. 


"His observation is that A-students who have excelled in an education system that does not tolerate failure, discourages partnership and puts a high premium on theory and rote knowledge is the worst training ground for developing entrepreneurs, businessmen, wealth creators.

However the C-students, rejected by the system are better suited to succeed financially because they are used to failure, knowing their intellectual limitations are more ready to collaborate and being outside the mainstream are used to swimming against the tide. The perfect qualifications to survive in business...


You don’t have to take his word for it. 

Look around you who are the most successful people – even by our warped standards of success? It is not the brightest students, but more likely it’s the people who know how to collaborate, lead and generally get things done.

The richer members of our society are no longer looking for grades. They are looking to grow rounded adults, exposed men and women equipped to operate in a globalised world. They can afford it.

"For the rest of us mere mortals it would be important for us to take a step back and ask ourselves whether forcing our kids into the latest meat factory to cram how to read, write and count is the best preparation for a future where knowledge is pervasive. In the future it will not be what is contained in one’s head that will count but whether one can find the information needed and manipulate it to solve the pressing questions of the day...  

Pressure is good. If handled well it forces us to expand our limits and grow. However it can be applied to the wrong priorities and count for nothing.

For Joan we all owe her an apology. For not only forcing her down a path that clearly did not fit her skill set but also for not providing her the alternatives and supporting her in exploring them.

Joan is an extreme case but we see the pressure piling on our children’s little bodies as they brave the freezing pre-dawn cold to school laden with bags as heavy as themselves. Is it any wonder that our children are giving up on life before they have started living?

Monday, February 16, 2015

2016: THE BATTLE IS WELL AND TRULY JOINED



This week the National Resistance Movement (NRM) parliamentary caucus opened their now annual, retreat at Kyankwanzi.

It is an event that is impossible to ignore if only because the NRM makes two-thirds of members in the house. If you add the 43 independents – most of whom are allied to the movement, the ability to muscle through any legislation by the group is undeniable, even frightening.

During the retreat they harmonised their positions on various pieces of legislation but denied the issue of presidential age limits came up.

The constitution has it that Uganda’s presidents shall not be 75 years old and beyond. What is subject to interpretation is whether this means no one shall run when they are above that age or whether one will be obliged to leave office when he attains the number.

If hypothetically the NRM decided to cause the amendment, they on paper could very well do it as they need a two thirds majority to amend the constitution. They have shown themselves more than capable of doing this, as they did with lifting of the presidential two-term limit a decade ago. 


"From a purely political point of view the NRM is in the best place to be as a ruling party...


By design or accident all these meetings – the several caucuses and the national conference, enforce the perception that the party, despite its internal squabbling, is unified in its purpose and resolute in its determination to stay in power.

The same cannot be said for its friends across the road.

Concerns that this kind of power is not good for the political future of Uganda are valid. It does not bode well for a country when one vision dominates the political space. But then again does it matter, seeing as our economic stratification is non-existent with the overwhelming majority being peasants? Durable parties are built on the basis of economic interest.

Governments are not tolerant out of the goodness of their hearts but are compelled to be so if there is a real threat to their hold on power, in the way of alternative views of how the country should be governed which are widespread and popular. 

Seeing as the NRM has occupied most of the middle ground the opposition needs to position itself with a message that is counter to the NRM’s and then rally likeminded people and convince those seating on the fence to their way of thinking.

You don’t get the impression the opposition is doing this enough. It’s not good manners to kick a man when he is down but it’s a hard argument to counter.

The NRM on its part, having been in power for the better part of three decades needs to guard against complacency.


"Buoyed by a winning personality and unlimited resources they should guard against going the way of the Kenya’s KANU which was in power for almost 40 years but folded like a pack of cards once its leading lights Jomo Kenyatta and Daniel arap Moi were out of power....


It’s kind of sad though that the opposition may have to rely on the patience of Job rather than a contest of near equals to unseat the NRM, because a stronger more vibrant opposition would force NRM to up its game in order to remain relevant. 

As it is now the opposition are looking the more jaded of the two making another NRM victory in 2016 an almost mathematical certainty.


Must Read

BOOK REVIEW: MUSEVENI'S UGANDA; A LEGACY FOR THE AGES

The House that Museveni Built: How Yoweri Museveni’s Vision Continues to Shape Uganda By Paul Busharizi  On sale HERE on Amazon (e-book...