Wednesday, September 24, 2014

THE COST OF CORRUPTION IS HARD TO MEASURE

A recent talk “The hidden costs of rent seeking in Uganda’s financial sector” reminded me of an article many years ago, about how trust plays an important role in economies.

The talk given by Professor Sam Sejjaaka outlined how rent seeking – a euphemism for corruption, is raising the cost of borrowing, encouraging misapplication of valuable resources and cannot be guaranteed to have a universal benefit.

Going by last year’s annual accounts, he pointed out that banking industry wrote off sh206b as bad loans or almost 40 percent of the industry’s profitability. This statistic pointed to a high risk environment. A lot of the bad loans did not come about out of genuine market failure but through the connivance of bank officials and borrowers in falsifying securities and flouting regulations to lend money to individuals who have no intention of repaying the money. These bad loans are a cost to the industry, which force up the cost of credit for upright borrowers.

On a more global level corruption hurts the economy by diverting resources away from innovation, which is at the heart of growing economies. Why think very hard when you can steal public funds?
Speaking at the function that was hosted by the US Ambassador Scott Delisi, Sejjaka’s solution to the scourge it would seem, emanates from what he considers the root of corruption not only in the financial sector. Moral hazard, where those charged with decision making are insulated from the consequences of their actions. So make them accountable and moral hazard will disappear and corruption will follow suit.

Which brings us to the role of trust in economies. World Bank economist Steve Knack reported about a decade ago that trust accounted for 99.5% of the US’ economic output. Put another way if the US GDP was $1000 that portion that would be attributable to hardwork is a mere $5...

This means that the more trust there is an economy the better it is able to grow.

He explained that there were two kinds of trust – personal and institutionalised. Strong economies have more of the latter than lesser developed nations. But institutionalised trust is derived from personal trust. A country’s institutions are only as trustworthy as its peoples are perceived to be.

Think of a situation where trust is very low and one has to buy sugar from the shop. First of all because you trust no one else, you would go down to the shops yourself to buy the sugar. Forgoing more productive endevours to do so. At the shop you will insist on transacting with only one shopkeeper and even then will whip out your chemistry set and portable weighing scale to make sure you are getting what you are paying for.

Now extrapolate this across thousands, even millions of transactions in a day and it’s easy to see how the economy would be affected.

And credit cannot operate in a low trust situation. Without credit there will always be a ceiling on how big economies can grow.

Up to about 15 years ago when the banks started unsecured lending, the middle class was much smaller. But using salaries as collateral for borrowing, the lending to the private sector has exploded and it is reflected in the expansion of Kampala out into previously godforsaken areas, increased traffic on the roads and increased demand for goods and services.


Trust while intangible means more for this economy than all the roads, dams, schools and hospitals you can build.


Corruption is not only increasing the cost of doing business, but is also widening income inequalities and threatening social stability.

Actually we should focus more on opportunity inequalities, which lead to income inequalities.

When because the of corruption schools go unbuilt and under facilitated, hospitals go unequipped and roads are eaten up by portholes, it is not unlike kicking the ladder away by the rich and powerful so that other people cannot join them at the party.

Various figures have been bandied around about the cost of corruption to this economy. The world Bank estimated that at least sh300b was being pilfered, a figure that was dismissed by some as not reflecting the scale of the situation.

But the anecdotal evidence is there for all to see.

Tuesday, September 23, 2014

IS SOUTH SUDAN LETTING THE SUN GET TO THEIR HEADS?



Last week South Sudan announced that it was giving all immigrant workers a month within which to leave their jobs for the locals.

According to the notice companies and Non-governmental organisations were directed in the meantime, to advertise all the positions that were due to fall vacant by the 15th of October.

As we were still trying to wrap our minds around this announcement the government did a quick about face and said the earlier communication misrepresented the official position. The new position is only seeking to take  the non-specialised, menial jobs back from immigrant workers and pass them on to their own citizens.

In the same week our southern neighbour Rwanda, which has the most liberal immigrant worker policies in the region, had its leader President Paul Kagame saying,

"The foundation of all our efforts is good governance, which for us means a relentless focus on delivering the results that citizens want. Building a competitive, modern economy requires smart investments in human capital, and productive knowledge. After all, real wealth is in the head, not in the ground"

Given this perspective it easy to see why Rwanda sees no contradiction between attracting foreign talent and delivering results for its citizens. Of course one can expect that even in Rwanda they will parcel out only the jobs they themselves cannot do. And as their own citizens understudy their foreign bosses it is realistic to expect that they will rise to fill even these jobs.

The South Sudanese are within their rights to do whatever they want with their country. But oftentimes such sweeping proclamations are political statements made to play to a gallery and not necessarily good for the long term benefit of the country.

With oil flowing less copiously than it was two years ago, Juba is under pressure to not only keep the general population happy but to appease supporters and foes alike.

"Expelling foreign nationals who have been fanning feelings of xenophobia by charging around in four wheel drives, living a lifestyle way out of the reach of most locals and generally seeming to be plucking the ripe fruit from right under their noses, can score some much needed political points...

The quick turnaround only serves to placate fears temporarily, but one can expect that whenever tensions erupt it will be a trump card played with disturbing frequency.

After decades of civil war one cannot blame South Sudan for its incoherence, a product of its lack of institutional and human capacity. This is all the more reason, like Rwanda whose middle class was decimated by the genocide, for them to be eager to import the human resource to fill in the gaping holes in its numbers.

Politicians don’t like free movement of people because then they cannot exert influence over them. However good economics suggests that the free movement of people is not only good for trade but for technology transfer or put more simply the exchange of knowledge for greater efficiency.

There is a reason for example that the Eurasia region developed almost in parallel than say Africa where there were pockets of civilisation in north, west, east and southern Africa but no real connections between them.

Because of the alignment of Europe and Asia for east to west, climate was more or less uniform so agricultural practices could be shared from the Atlantic to the Pacific. The similarities in their produce meant shortages could be mitigated by surpluses from across the world using trade if need be, since tastes were similar. Of course other things were then shared, with each innovation building on the previous and being pollinated by advances from elsewhere and voila we have the foundations of word dominance.

Africa aligned from north to south just could not replicate these benefits and hence its relative backwardness.


The point is, while immigrant labour is an easy political target, hobbling it is often bad economics.
And South Sudan, which is thrice the size of Uganda but with barely a 100 km of tarmac road, is in desperate need of some good economic thinking.


The people in charge in Juba need to come fast to the realisation that people are what make the difference.
You can choose to use nationality over competence as a criteria for recruitment and it might for a while keep your people happy, but it will come around to bite you when your government is unable “to deliver the results that your citizens want.”
The pressure on government must be overwhelming but this is where leadership comes into play. Juba needs to pander less to political expediency and more and more to the bigger picture, the long term view, if it is to have a chance of lifting the war torn country into the 21st century.

Monday, September 22, 2014

EBOLA: ONE MORE REASON TO BEEF UP OUR RESEARCH


This week it was announced that deaths due to Ebola has hit the 2,400 mark. President Barack Obama labelled the crisis a “global security threat” and committed funds and manpower to battle the latest outbreak.

It would not be lost on many that it has taken more than six months for the leader of the free world to acknowledge the danger.

The conspiracy theorists have been having a field day. They find it strange that a disease whose previous outbreaks have been characterised by jungle or rural set ups, in west Africa reared its ugly head in the urban settings.

They also wonder at the speed at which it has spread across borders. And finally that there were doses of a trial anti-Ebola drug available conveniently to heal two US doctors and UK paramedic.

It’s possible that these theories would not stand up to much scrutiny and that they have got innocent and logical reasons to explain them away.

But what is not under contest is that no drug has been created to battle the deadly virus, which was first isolated almost 40 years ago in 1976.

"The reason this is, is a reflection of the low profitability associated with such a drug by the big pharmaceuticals, the relatively few deaths attributed to it and the lack of capacity to develop a drug by the populations most likely to suffer Ebola attacks – namely poor African countries...

The five biggest health killers in the western world are heart disease, respiratory diseases, stroke, cancer and liver disease. In Africa on the other hand it is Tuberclosis, AIDS, Malaria and water borne diseases.

The pharmaceutical industry is driven by private capital. This means that for them to research and develop a drug a business case has to be made. So you find most of the research is driven towards western ailments and less towards diseases that affect the world’ poor.

The US National Cancer Institute reports that $4.9b has been spent per year for the last six years on cancer research, while it is estimated that to get at least 500,000 doses of an Ebola vaccine within the next nine months can cost $25m.

In addition over four decades it is estimated that only about 4000 people have died from the hemorrhagic fever, a number that does not help in making a case for a possible vaccine’s viability.
The bottom line is that for the big pharmaceutical companies who have the resources – financial and human to research and develop drugs for Ebola or any other diseases that affect us, it does not make financial sense to get involved.

Which brings us full circle to our own responsibility as Africans.  Ebola and several other diseases are our diseases, by virtue of our climate and proximity to nature. They are our problem. It does not take a rocket scientist to work out that as a continent we need to invest more into research and development for these diseases that are uniquely ours...

In fact state subsidies of research – medical or agriculture would be money well spent. And it is not for lack of money that we do not get involved in such worthwhile endeavour, but for a lack of leadership on the continent to identify our problems and come up with solutions to them. We have the finances and we can develop the man power to push such a project.

The African has shown himself to be resilient to conquest, disease and poverty but that resilience should not be taken for granted. We need to start thinking strategically if we as a continent are to rise to our full potential. Medical research is as good a p lace as any to start.

Wednesday, September 17, 2014

REALIGNING THE STATE WITH THE PEOPLE’S ASPIRATIONS



What is corruption? Corruption is the employment of public goods for personal enrichment.

Or maybe we should add, employment of public goods for personal, family and friends’ enrichment.
By this definition corruption goes beyond stealing money, but will include employing company facilities – using official cars to ferry charcoal or official computers to do private consultancies or official time to do private errands.

To complete the definition we might add, corruption is the employment of public/company goods for personal, family and friends’ enrichment. And you can be sure we have not covered all the bases.

Corruption comes from a misalignment of ambitions between the government officials and the public or between the employees and shareholders or clients. If you can align those two ambitions, corruption need not exist. I think.

"The theory is that governments are in place to improve the welfare of their people, be it in terms of improved security, services and infrastructure. Generally governments are, or should be, in the business of creating a conducive environment for their people, to not only survive but thrive...

It is not automatic.

For government to execute its mandate, its bureaucracy needs to one, appreciate the end goal and two, make their own personal ambitions subservient to this overarching goal.
Without the latter it will matter little if everyone understands the former.

So under what circumstances do personal greed override the well-meaning intentions of the government?

It progresses slowly but increases in pace as more and more people are roped into the scam.
It starts when the bar of what is considered corrupt is raised. One minister famously complained that he had only eaten a few hundreds of thousands of dollars when others had eaten more. That the press should stop witch-hunting him!

Proceeds on to when public officials get away with more and more without getting caught. When we hear official so-so and the other have stolen billions of shillings it rarely is it the case that they did it in one fell sweep. Often times the stolen billions are the cumulative effect of years of “hard” work.

And then when the bosses start co-opting subordinates in their shady deals.

The story is told of former Zaire now Democratic Republic of Congo president Mobutu Ssese SSeko. Whenever he wanted some money from the central bank he would send his personal assistant with a note for say $10,000, the personal assistant would trot over to the central bank, but only after adding a zero to the request to make it $100,000. The central bank governor would unlock the vaults,  but only after adding his own zero to make it $1,000,000.
So at the end Mobutu pocketed his $10,000 (maybe even tipped his PA $100!), the PA got $90,000 and the central bank boss got $900,000. Makes you wonder whether Mobutu was truly the richest man in Zaire.

And finally the institution becomes a machine for the promotion of private enrichment for its officials. It may even hire out its competence to people outside.


Of course the logical conclusion to all this is that eventually the government is captured, it forgets its original raison d’etre and becomes a free-for-all-but-the-people eating spree.


By this time even inserting your most upright citizens to cause a clean-up is an exercise in futility, as the “eating” networks are so pervasive and coordinated that the most righteous individual will soon be subsumed by the sheer magnitude of the racket.

And the people?

Well they will get a few crumbs when the officials charge down to the village in government monster four wheel drives or to pay fees in decrepit schools, in a bad state because they do not get enough funding for the government or a few contributions for weddings, whose standards have been blown out of all reasonableness by the example of these thieving officials' own parties.

Actually the worst thing that can happen is not that the government becomes a machine feeding off the people’s sweat for the enrichment of the few. The worst thing that can happen is that the whole population – the thieves and victims, slowly but with increasing pace accept this state of affairs as the new normal.

When your brightest minds clamour for government jobs over the private sector, where the jobs are more enriching – in the sense of professional development and advancement you know all is lost.
Thankfully that last part has not happened in Uganda. Not yet!

Must Read

BOOK REVIEW: MUSEVENI'S UGANDA; A LEGACY FOR THE AGES

The House that Museveni Built: How Yoweri Museveni’s Vision Continues to Shape Uganda By Paul Busharizi  On sale HERE on Amazon (e-book...