Monday, October 8, 2018

WE WANT TO GO TO HEAVEN, BUT WE DON’T WANT TO DIE

Wouldn’t it be great if every time we fell sick wherever we are in the country, we could walk into a health facility not have to endure long tortuous queues and still get quality services at the end of the brief wait?

Wouldn’t it be great if when we gave birth to our kids we were assured of a first class education all the way to university – and beyond?

Wouldn’t it be great if in addition to expansive highways we had high speed rail networks and affordable air connections within the country and to foreign destinations?

There is a place like that on this earth.

My friend who visited Helsinki the capital of Finland a few years ago has the best anecdote of the safe country we would love to see. The family they were visiting with ordered a flat screen TV online. On the day they were not home their TV was delivered and since the delivery man did not have access to the home he left the TV on the porch, we call it a veranda. Hours later the family returned home to the pleasant surprise that their TV had been delivered, took it in and installed it.

My friend eight years later, has not yet recovered from the shock that that was possible.

"Of course it was not always like this. The high living standards in Finland and Scandinavia have come after generations of interaction between the ruling elite and the citizenry...

So for example while the average annual government expenditure per citizen is about €10,000 (sh40m) the revenue to GDP collections in Finland stood at about 44.1 percent.

The comparable figures for Uganda are sh800,000 and 14 percent.

It is not rocket science if we want the good life we have to pay for it.

Of course the common refrain is that this government is too corrupt and it is affecting service delivery. The anecdotal evidence flies right in your face and it is hard to refute, so I will be the last to vouch for the integrity of our government.

"But truth too is that government has very little to work with. In effect in every sector of the economy even roads and electricity the resources available to them are hardly enough to do anything effectively.
And to make it worse they are trying to do everything, spreading themselves very thin and doing nothing particularly well...

For instance this year’s health budget comes in at sh1.9trillion or about sh47,500 per person. This is even more pitiful when you consider that of this money the cash spent on health worker salaries and medicine is sh810b or sh20,250 per person per year.

Even allowing for the proverbial corruption government is working with too little money to get anything done.

It therefore beats my understanding how our Members of Parliament can oppose new taxes on mobile money and social media – an effort to rope more people into the tax base and yet complain that government is failing to deliver services and even worse are watering at the mouth to increase their salaries yet again.

The way I see it government has two options neither of which are easy.

Either using the existing resources they decide in five year periods to focus on particular sectors and totally disregard others. So for example they decide that for the next five years we are going to push power and roads, bump their budgets like two to three times and the rest of the departments make do with whatever crumbs are left over. After the period an assessment is made on progress and decision is taken either to continue or choose other sectors.

The obvious political fallout cannot be underestimated.

Or government goes all out, hammer and tongs to collect all the taxes due to it from everybody who is liable. As it is now there about a million people who pay taxes on their income against a total workforce of 11 million.

Understandably there will be gritting of teeth all over the country at this, with opportunistic politicians leveraging it to increase the government’s unpopularity, but somebody is going to have to do it sooner than later.

"Given the miserable numbers the government is spending on every citizen the time of reckoning has long past. To stem poverty and all its ills – population growth, insecurity and disease, the government budget has to grow exponentially. For that to happen we all have to pay taxes....

And as for fighting corruption, how can government guard against corruption when its law enforcement and accountability agencies are not funded?

If we want to go to heaven (live a first world lifestyle), we need to prepare for death (paying taxes).


3 comments:

  1. Leaving the politics alone, Ugandans are not against paying taxes. Some decisions simply do not auger well, continuous creation of administrative units increases the cost of public administration.

    The limited government efforts to systematically support the informal sector as part of getting more business formalized so that more people are eligible to taxes.

    The ever widening gap between the poor and rich that goes unattended. Selectively offers tax holidays to investors with insufficient safeguards for home grown entrepreneurs.

    Governments unsustainable practices of giving handouts to able citizens which turns them into dependents is self defeating.



    Sauti za Wananchi data collected from 1,925 respondents between 12 and 30 May, 2018 revealed that, A majority of citizens (62%) say the main thing that someone needs in order to improve their status in life is to work hard.

    What citizens need is an environment that enables them to work, they need access to affordable credit, they need mechanisms that buffer them against against shocks, fuel prices have to be reasonable and the relevant skills to given our context.

    Ugandans are more concerned about sustainable improvements to their livelihoods, rather than quick fixes, Sauti za Wananchi data March 2018.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You didnt read the full article did you? if you had you would have noticed the point that government is playing with little resources to begin with so environment to work, affordable credit mechanisms against shocks where are these supposed to come from? in fact these cost much more than the tocken monies govt hands out which draw a lot of publicity but whose net value is low

      Delete
    2. And yes given a choice Ugandans like other people will not pay tax .... the mzungu pays tax in his home because there are severe penalties if they do not, not because they are inherently tax paying people

      Delete